British Journal of Canadian Studies

Contesting natural resource development in Canada: the legacies and limits of the staples approach

British Journal of Canadian Studies (2018), 31, (2), 167–179.

Abstract

Harold Innis (1930) famously described Canada as a country comprised of ‘hewers of wood and drawers of water’. The staples approach that he advanced and which his followers subsequently further developed has become a reference point for continuing debate over the economic importance and consequences of natural resource development in Canada, a debate reignited by the long commodities boom of 2000–14. In this article we examine another, overlooked legacy of the staples approach, namely, the ways in which its emphasis on linkages has provided a frame of reference for opponents of natural resource projects. This is illustrated by examining some of the contemporary contestations of resource projects in northern British Columbia. These examples also show, however, that the staples approach provides only a partial frame of reference for contemporary contestations; more recent concerns such as Indigenous rights, procedural fairness, and environmental issues also play a significant role in oppositional politics to resource projects. Nevertheless, our discussion shows that Canada at 150 is still debating the role that natural resource development should play, and that the legacy of the staples approach continues to play a role in the debate.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

References

Bowles, Paul, and Fiona MacPhail, 2017, ‘The Town That Said “No” to the Enbridge Northern Gateway Pipeline: The 2014 Kitimat Plebiscite’, The Extractive Industries and Society, 4:1, 15–23. Google Scholar

Bowles, Paul, and Gary Wilson (eds), 2015, Resource Communities in a Globalizing Region: Development, Agency and Contestation in Northern British Columbia (Vancouver, BC: UBC Press). Google Scholar

Carroll, William, 1986, Corporate Power and Canadian Capitalism (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press). Google Scholar

Chetkiewicz, Cheryl, and Anastasia M. Lintner, 2014, Getting It Right in Ontario’s Far North: The Need for Regional Strategic Environmental Assessment in the Ring of Fire [Wawangajing], Wildlife Conservation Society Canada and Ecojustice Canada. Available from: https://www.wcscanada.org/Portals/96/Documents/RSEA_Report_WCSCanada_Ecojustice_FINAL.pdf (accessed 20 July 2018). Google Scholar

Drache, Daniel, 1991, ‘Harold Innis and Canadian Capitalist Development’, in Gordon Laxer (ed.), Perspectives on Canadian Economic Development: Class, Staples, Gender and Elites (Don Mills, ON: Oxford University Press), pp. 22–49. Google Scholar

Drews, Keven, 2013, ‘HD Mining Foreign Workers Case Dismissed by Federal Court’, The Canadian Press, 21 May. Google Scholar

Ghoussoub, Michelle, 2017, ‘Pacific NorthWest LNG Project in Port Edward, B.C., No Longer Proceeding’, 25 July, CBC News. Available from: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-columbia/pacific-northwest-lng-project-in-port-edward-b-c-no-longer-proceeding-1.4220936 (accessed 10 June 2018). Google Scholar

Government of British Columbia, 2012, ‘British Columbia Outlines Requirements for Heavy Oil Pipeline Consideration’, Released 23 July. Available from: https://news.gov.bc.ca/stories/british-columbia-outlines-requirements-for-heavy-oil-pipeline-consideration (accessed 16 November 2018). Google Scholar

Graham, Nicholas, Shannon Daub, and Bill Carroll, 2017, Mapping Political Influence: Political Influence and Lobbying in the Fossil Fuel Industry in BC (Vancouver, BC: Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives). Google Scholar

Gunton, Thomas, 2003, ‘Natural Resources and Regional Development: An Assessment of Dependency and Comparative Advantage Paradigms’, Economic Geography, 79:1, 67–94. Google Scholar

Hayter, Roger, and Trevor Barnes, 1990, ‘Innis’ Staple Theory, Exports and Recession: British Columbia 1981–86’, Economic Geography, 60:2, 156–73. Google Scholar

Hirschman, Albert O., 2013, ‘A Generalized Linkage Approach to Development, with Special Reference to Staples’, in Jeremy Adelman (ed.), The Essential Hirschman (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press), pp. 155–93. Google Scholar

Innis, Harold, 1930, The Fur Trade in Canada: An Introduction to Canadian Economic History (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). Google Scholar

Kellogg, Paul, 2015, Escaping the Staples Trap (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). Google Scholar

Krauss, Clifford, and Ian Austen, 2014, ‘Rocky Road for Canadian Oil’, The New York Times, 12 May. Google Scholar

Laxer, Gordon, 2015, After the Sands: Energy and Ecological Security for Canadians (Vancouver: Douglas & McIntyre). Google Scholar

Poloz, Stephen, 2016, ‘From Hewers of Wood to Hewers of Code: Canada’s Expanding Service Economy’, Remarks by the Governor of the Bank of Canada at the C.D. Howe Institute, Toronto, 28 November, Bank of Canada. Google Scholar

Sharp, Karyn, 2014, ‘Karyn Sharp’, in Paul Bowles and Henry Veltmeyer (eds), The Answer Is Still No: Voices of Pipeline Resistance (Black Point, NS: Fernwood), pp. 15–25. Google Scholar

Stanford, Jim, 2008, ‘Staples, Deindustrialization, and Foreign Investment: Canada’s Economic Journey Back to the Future’, Studies in Political Economy, 82, 7–34. Google Scholar

Stanford, Jim, (ed.), 2014, ‘The Staple Theory @ 50: Reflections on the Lasting Significance of Mel Watkins’ “A Staple Theory of Economic Growth”’, Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives. Available from: https://www.policyalternatives.ca/publications/reports/staple-theory-50 (accessed 20 July 2018). Google Scholar

Tabor, Jane, 2006, ‘PM brands Canada an “Energy Superpower””, The Globe and Mail, 15 July. Google Scholar

Watkins, Mel, 2006a, ‘A Staple Theory of Economic Growth’, in Hugh Grant and David A. Wolfe (eds), Staples and Beyond: Selected Writings of Mel Watkins (Montreal, QC and Kingston, ON: McGill-Queen’s University Press), pp. 5–29. Google Scholar

Watkins, Mel, 2006b, ‘The Staple Theory Revisited’, in Hugh Grant and David A. Wolfe (eds), Staples and Beyond: Selected Writings of Mel Watkins (Montreal, QC and Kingston, ON: McGill-Queen’s University Press), pp. 30–50. Google Scholar

Watkins, Mel, 2006c, ‘The Dene Nation: From Underdevelopment to Development’, in Hugh Grant and David A. Wolfe (eds), Staples and Beyond: Selected Writings of Mel Watkins (Montreal, QC and Kingston, ON: McGill-Queen’s University Press), pp. 51–70. Google Scholar

Wellstead, Adam, 2008, ‘The (Post) Staples Economy and the (Post) Staples State in Historical Perspective’, in Michael Howlett and Keith Brownsey (eds), Canada’s Resource Industry in Transition: The Past, Present and Future of Canadian Staples Industries (Toronto, ON: Emond Montgomery), pp. 19–38. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Bowles, Paul

MacPhail, Fiona