Charlie Hebdo and the politics of mourning

Balkan, Osman

doi:https://doi.org/10.3828/cfc.2016.13

Balkan, Osman

Contemporary French Civilization (2016), 41, (2), 253–271.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3828/cfc.2016.13
Language: English
Pages: 19

Abstract

This article explores the different forms of mourning that structured the public and political memorialization of the victims and perpetrators of the Paris attacks by analyzing the discourses, ceremonies, and negotiations accompanying their funerals. It argues that political actors employed three distinct strategies of mourning to produce a hierarchy of French subjects organized around a spectrum of grievability. The first strategy, “mourning as erasure,” was characteristic of the funerals of the three terrorists and evinced an active effort by the French state to efface any trace of their memory. The second, “mourning as exclusionary-inclusion,” was exemplified in the ceremonies held in honor of Ahmed Merabet, a police officer mourned as a loyal guardian of the French Republic in terms that maintained his subordinate status as a religious outsider. The third strategy, “mourning as appropriation,” was most pronounced at the funerals of the four victims of the attack on the kosher supermarket Hyper Cacher. Held in Israel, these ceremonies offered an emotional platform for both French and Israeli leaders to claim the Jewish victims as their own. These disparate strategies of mourning highlight the different ways that the dead help demarcate the boundaries of political communities.

Cet article examine les différents modes de deuil qui structurent la commémoration publique et politique des victimes et des responsables des attentats de Paris en analysant les discours, les cérémonies, et les négociations concernant leurs funérailles. Cet article affirme que les acteurs politiques emploient trois stratégies différentes de deuil pour créer une hiérarchie de sujets français organisée autour d’un éventail de modes et de degrés de deuil. La première stratégie, “le deuil d’effacement,” fût caractéristique des funérailles des trois terroristes et fit preuve d’un effort actif de l’État français d’effacer toute trace de leur mémoire. La deuxième stratégie, “le deuil d’exclusion-inclusion,” fût illustrée par les cérémonies en mémoire d’Ahmed Merabet, un policier pleuré pour avoir loyalement protégé la république Française, mais en des termes qui servirent à maintenir sa position subordonnée en fonction de son appartenance religieuse. La troisième stratégie, “le deuil d’appropriation,” fût surtout notable lors des funérailles des quatre victimes de l’attaque du supermarché Hyper Cacher. Ces cérémonies, tenues en Israël, furent utilisées par les personnalités françaises et israéliennes pour revendiquer les victimes Juives comme les leurs. Ces stratégies de deuil distinctes montrent les différentes façons dont les morts participent à la production des frontières qui démarquent les communautés politiques.

FormatArticle

£25.00

READ THIS ARTICLE

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

AFP. “Charlie Hebdo: le Policier Ahmed Merabet enterré à Bobigny.” L’Express. Web. >http://www.lexpress.fr/actualites/1/actualite/charlie-hebdo-debut-des-obseques-du-policier ahmed-merabet-a-bobigny_1640231.html>. 13 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“Algeria Rejects Kouachi Brothers’ Bodies.” Anadolu Agency. Web. >http://aa.com.tr/en/world/algeria-rejects-kouachi-brothers-bodies/83279>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Balkan, Osman. “Burial and Belonging.” Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism 15.1 (2015): 120–34. Burial and Belonging Studies in Ethnicity and Nationalism 15.1 120 34 Google Scholar

Bargu, Banu. “Sovereignty as Erasure: Rethinking Enforced Disappearances.” Qui Parle 23.1 (2014): 35–75. Sovereignty as Erasure: Rethinking Enforced Disappearances Qui Parle 23.1 35 75 Google Scholar

de la Baume, Maïa. “For Charlie Hebdo Gunman, a Discreet Burial in Reims.” New York Times. Web. >http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/18/world/europe/paris-attacks-charlie-hebdo.html?_r=0>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

de la Baume, Maïa, and Dan Bilefsky. “Bodies of French Gunmen Lie Unburied, and, it Appears, Mostly Unwanted.” New York Times. Web. >http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/16/world/europe/bodies-of-french-gunmen-lie-unburied-and-largely-unwanted.html?_r=0>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Bilefsky, Dan. “François Hollande Vows to Defend France’s Republican Ideals.” New York Times. Web. >http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/06/world/europe/hollande-vows-to-defend-frances-republican-ideals.html>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Bontinck, Jean-Gabriel. “Le dernier au revoir à Ahmed Merabet” Le Parisien. Web. >http://www.leparisien.fr/espace-premium/fait-du-jour/le-dernier-au-revoir-a-ahmed-merabet-14-01-2015-4444153.php>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Booth, William, and Ruth Eglash. “Come Home, Israeli Leaders Urge Jews in France.” Washington Post 12 Jan. 2015. A07. Come Home, Israeli Leaders Urge Jews in France Washington Post Google Scholar

Butler, Judith. Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence. New York: Verso, 2004. Precarious Life: The Powers of Mourning and Violence Google Scholar

Butler, Judith. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? New York: Verso, 2010. Frames of War: When Is Life Grievable? Google Scholar

“Chérif Kouachi devrait être enterré à Gennevilliers sans son frère Said.” France TV Info. Web. >http://www.francetvinfo.fr/economie/medias/charlie-hebdo/cherif-kouachi-devrait-etre-enterre-a-gennevilliers-sans-son-frere-said_799485.html>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“Code général des collectivités territoriales – Article L2223-3.” Legifrance. Web. >http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichCodeArticle.do?cidTexte=LEGITEXT000006070633&idArticle=LEGIARTI000019983137>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

D’Adler, Marie-Ange. Le cimetière musulman de Bobigny: lieu de mémoire d’un siècle d’immigration. Paris: Éditions Autrement, 2008. Delhon-Bugard, Gautier. “Attentats à Paris: l’un des terroristes du Bataclan a été inhume en toute discretion à La Courneuve.” RTL. Web. >http://www.rtl.fr/actu/societe-faits-divers/attentats-a-paris-l-un-des-terroristes-du-bataclan-a-ete-inhume-en-toute-discretion-a-la-courneuve-7781039387>. 17 Feb. 2016. Google Scholar

Dvorin, Tova, and Yoni Kempinski. “Funeral for Paris Victims Held in Jerusalem.” Israel National News. Web. >http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/189876>. 13 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“L’encombrante dépouille de Merah enterrée en France.” Le Parisien. Web. >http://www.leparisien.fr/espace-premium/actu/l-encombrante-depouille-de-merah-enterree-en-france-30-03-2012-1930593.php>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Fernando, Mayanthi. The Republic Unsettled: Muslim French and the Contradictions of Secularism. Durham: Duke University Press, 2014. The Republic Unsettled: Muslim French and the Contradictions of Secularism Google Scholar

Foucault, Michel. The History of Sexuality, Volume 1. New York: Vintage Books, 1990. The History of Sexuality, Volume 1 Google Scholar

Fikri, Mehdi. “Ahmed Merabet: flic et musulman.” L’Humanité. Web. >http://www.humanite.fr/ahmed-merabet-flic-et-musulman-562753>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“Frédéric Boisseau, ‘première victime des attentats’ de ‘Charlie Hebdo’, a été inhumé.” Le Monde. Web. >http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2015/01/20/frederic-boisseau-premiere-victime-des-attentats-de-charlie-hebdo-a-ete-inhume_4560040_3224.html#>. 12 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Gauron, Roland. “Amedy Coulibaly a été enterré dans le cimetière parisien de Thiais.” Le Figaro. Web. >http://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/2015/01/23/01016-20150123ARTFIG00178-amedy-coulibaly-a-ete-enterre-dans-le-cimetiere-parisien-de-thiais.php>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Ginsburg, Mitch, and Gabe Fisher. “‘God Will Avenge Your Deaths’, Cries Israel’s Chief Rabbi at Funeral of Tolouse Victims.” The Times of Israel. Web. >http://www.timesofisrael.com/four-toulouse-victims-being-buried-in-jerusalem/>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Goldberg, Jeffrey. “French Prime Minister: If Jews Flee, the Republic Will Be a Failure.” The Atlantic. Web. >http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2015/01/french-prime-minister-warns-if-jews-flee-the-republic-will-be-judged-a-failure/384410/>. 12 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Hasson, Nir. “State Pressured Paris Attack Victim’s Family to Bury Him in Israel.” Ha’aretz. Web. >http://www.haaretz.com/jewish-world/jewish-world-news/.premium-1.636979>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Hertz, Robert. Death and the Right Hand. Trans. Rodney and Claudia Needham. Aberdeen: University Press, 1960. Death and the Right Hand Google Scholar

“Hommage à Frédéric Boisseau.” Ministère du Travail, de l’Emploi, de la Formation professionnelle et du Dialogue social. Web. >http://travail-emploi.gouv.fr/actualite-presse,42/discours,2142/hommage-a-frederic-boisseau,18391.html>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“Hommage aux victimes: l’intégralité du discours de François Hollande.” Daily Motion. Web. >http://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2en42r_hommage-aux-victimes-l-integralite-du-discours-de-francois-hollande_news>. 13 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Honig, Bonnie. “Antigone’s Laments, Creon’s Grief: Mourning, Membership, and the Politics of Exception.” Political Theory 37.1 (2009): 5–43. Antigone’s Laments, Creon’s Grief: Mourning, Membership, and the Politics of Exception Political Theory 37.1 5 43 Google Scholar

Kselman, Thomas. “Funeral Conflicts in Nineteenth-Century France” Comparative Studies in Society and History 30.2 (1988): 312–32. Funeral Conflicts in Nineteenth-Century France Comparative Studies in Society and History 30.2 312 32 Google Scholar

Lang, Geoffroy. “Attentats à Paris: un des terroristes du Bataclan enterré dans le Val-de-Marne.” RTL. Web. >http://www.rtl.fr/actu/societe-faits-divers/attentats-a-paris-un-des-terroristes-du-bataclan-enterre-dans-le-val-de-marne-7781859988>. 17 Feb. 2016. Google Scholar

“Martinique: solennité, emotion et tristesse aux obsequies de Clarissa Jean-Philippe.” AFP. Web. >http://www.ladepeche.fr/article/2015/01/20/2032530-martinique-solennite-emotion-tristesse-obseques-clarissa-jean-philippe.html>. 12 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Nelson, Steve. “Je ne suis pas Charlie!” Huffington Post. Web. >http://www.huffing-tonpost.com/steve-nelson/je-ne-suis-pas-charlie_1_b_6497284.html>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Norton, Anne. “Charlie Hebdo and Europe’s Rising Right.” Huffington Post. Web. >http://www.huffingtonpost.com/anne-norton/charlie-hebdo-and-europes_b_6444368.html>. 17 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Ozouf, Mona. Festivals and the French Revolution. Trans. Alan Sheridan. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1988. Festivals and the French Revolution Google Scholar

Pool, Heather. “The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging.” Polity 44.2 (2012): 182–211. The Politics of Mourning: The Triangle Fire and Political Belonging Polity 44.2 182 211 Google Scholar

Ragon, Michel. The Space of Death: A Study of Funerary Architecture, Decoration, and Urbanism. Trans. Alan Sheridan. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 1983. The Space of Death: A Study of Funerary Architecture, Decoration, and Urbanism Google Scholar

Rousseau, Valentine, and Adrien Cadorel. “Le Mali refuse d’inhumer Amedy Coulibaly, sa dépouille reste en France.” Le Parisien. Web. >http://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/attentats-le-mali-refuse-d-inhumer-amedy-coulibaly-sa-depouille-reste-en-france-21-01-2015-4466905.php>. 13 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Rudoren, Jodi. “Emotion Mixes with Politics as 4 Killed at Paris Market are Buried in Jerusalem.” New York Times. Web. >http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/14/world/middleeast/paris-terror-attacks-funeral-jerusalem.html>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Sage, Adam. “Police Officers Were Bridge-builders.” The Times. Web. >http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/news/world/europe/article4318118.ece>. 12 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

“Saïd Kouachi enterré à Reims, Chérif Kouachi à Gennevilliers” Le Parisien. Web. >http://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/attentats-said-kouachi-enterre-a-reims-cherif-kouachi-a-gennevilliers-17-01-2015-4454915.php>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

de Sakutin, Stephane. “Frédéric Boisseau, ‘première victime des attentats’ de ‘Charlie Hebdo’, a été inhumé.” Le Monde. Web. >http://www.lemonde.fr/societe/article/2015/01/20/frederic-boisseau-premiere-victime-des-attentats-de-charlie-hebdo-a-ete-inhume_4560040_3224.html>. 13 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Saliceti, Dianna. “Le devenir incertain de la dépouille d’Amedy Coulibaly.” Libération. Web. >http://www.liberation.fr/societe/2015/01/22/le-devenir-incertain-de-la-depouille-d-amedy-coulibaly_1186636>. 14 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Sharon, Jeremy. “Families of Paris Terrorist Attack Victims Will not be Charged for Funerals.” Jerusalem Post. Web. >http://www.jpost.com/Diaspora/Ministry-of-Religious-Services-Families-of-Paris-terror-attack-victims-will-not-be-charged-387727>. 15 Jul. 2015. Google Scholar

Silverstein, Paul A. “Sporting Faith: Islam, Soccer, and the French Nation-State.” Social Text 65 18.4 (2000): 25–53. Sporting Faith: Islam, Soccer, and the French Nation-State Social Text 65 18.4 25 53 Google Scholar

Stepputat, Finn, ed. Governing the Dead: Sovereignty and the Politics of Dead Bodies. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2014. Governing the Dead: Sovereignty and the Politics of Dead Bodies Google Scholar

Stow, Simon. “Pericles at Gettysburg and Ground Zero: Tragedy, Patriotism, and Public Mourning.” American Political Science Review 101.2 (2010): 195–208. Pericles at Gettysburg and Ground Zero: Tragedy, Patriotism, and Public Mourning American Political Science Review 101.2 195 208 Google Scholar

Ural, Yasemin. “A Genealogy of Muslims Dying in France: Strasbourg Cemetery as a Contested Space.” Sociology of Islam 2 (2014): 1–20. A Genealogy of Muslims Dying in France: Strasbourg Cemetery as a Contested Space Sociology of Islam 2 1 20 Google Scholar

van den Breemer, Rosemarie, and Marcel Maussen. “On the Viability of State-Church Models: Muslim Burial and Mosque Building in France and the Netherlands.” Journal of Immigrant and Refugee Studies 10.30 (2012): 279–98. On the Viability of State-Church Models: Muslim Burial and Mosque Building in France and the Netherlands Journal of Immigrant and Refugee Studies 10.30 279 98 Google Scholar

Van Gennep, Arnold. The Rites of Passage. Trans. Monkia B. Vizedom and Gabrielle L. Caffee. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1960. The Rites of Passage Google Scholar

Verdery, Katherine. The Political Lives of Dead Bodies: Reburial and Post-Socialist Change. New York: Columbia University Press, 2000. The Political Lives of Dead Bodies: Reburial and Post-Socialist Change Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Balkan, Osman

Contemporary French Civilization