Town Planning Review

The social reconstruction of the marine environment: Towards marine spatial planning?

Town Planning Review (2004), 75, (3), 359–378.

Abstract

This paper critically considers the emerging idea of marine spatial planning as part of the wider debates associated with the social reconstruction of the marine environment and the rethinking around the conventional boundaries of land use planning. First, the paper seeks to define the contemporary understanding of the marine environmental agenda, following Hannigan's (1995) social constructionist perspective. Second, it traces the evolution of thinking towards the concept of marine spatial planning. This locates the discussion within the current European discourse of spatiality, and strategies for the conservation and sustainable development of the marine environment, together with the evolving ideas associated with the practical management of coastal areas. The argument presented here is that if as a society we are successfully to reconstruct a solution to the perceived marine problem then a paradigm shift is required in terms of how we socially reconstruct the problem. It argues that the current incremental extension of terrestrial land use planning controls over aspects of the marine environment, together with the advocacy of marine spatial planning, requires a much more critically robust theoretical understanding so as to encompass the rapidly changing agenda of change.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

ALDEN, J. (2001), 'Planning at a national scale: a new planning framework for the UK' in L. Albrecht, J. Alden and A. Da Rosa Pires (eds), The Changing Institutional Landscape of Planning, Aldershot, Ashgate, 55-82. Planning at a national scale: a new planning framework for the UK The Changing Institutional Landscape of Planning 55 82 Google Scholar

ALLMENDINGER, P., BARKER, A. and STEAD, S. (2002), 'Delivering integrated coastal zone management through land use planning', Planning Practice and Research, 17, 175-96. 'Delivering integrated coastal zone management through land use planning' Planning Practice and Research 17 175 96 Google Scholar

BARROW, C. J. (1999), Environment and Management: Principles and Practice, London, Routledge. Environment and Management: Principles and Practice Google Scholar

BAXTER, B. (2000), Ecologism: An Introduction, Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press. Ecologism: An Introduction Google Scholar

BERRY, C. (2000), Marine Health Check: A Report to Gauge the Health of the UK's Sea Life, Godalming, WWF-UK. Google Scholar

BULL, K. S. E, and LAFFOLEY, D. D'A. (2003), Networks of Protected Areas in the Maritime Environment (report for the Review of Marine Nature Conservation and the Marine Stewardship Process Stakeholder Workshop, London, 19 June 2003), (English Nature Research Report, No. 537), Peterborough, English Nature. Google Scholar

BURBRIDGE, P. and BURBRIDGE, V. (1994), Review of Scottish Coastal Issues, Edinburgh, Scottish Office. Review of Scottish Coastal Issues Google Scholar

BURBRIDGE, P. and HUMPHREY, S. (2003), 'Introduction' (Special Issue on the European Demonstration Programme on Integrated Coastal Zone Management), Coastal Management, 31, 121-26. Google Scholar

BURNINGHAM, H., DUCK, R. W. and WATT, A. M. (2000), 'Perspectives from a newly formed ICZM Partnership: the Tay Estuary Forum', Periodicum Biologorum, 102, 101-05. 'Perspectives from a newly formed ICZM Partnership: the Tay Estuary Forum' Periodicum Biologorum 102 101 05 Google Scholar

BUTTEL, F. H. (1987), 'New directions in environmental sociology', Annual Review of Sociology, 13, 465-88. 'New directions in environmental sociology' Annual Review of Sociology 13 465 88 Google Scholar

CHRISTIE, I., SOUTHGATE, M. and WARBURTON, D. (undated), Living Spaces: A Vision for the Future of Planning, Sandy, Royal Society for the Protection of Birds. Google Scholar

COASTAL ZONE MANAGEMENT IN THE EUROPEAN UNION, Various reports, > http://www.icm.noaa.gov/globalinfo/eu/eu.html Google Scholar

CONNELLY, J. and SMITH, G. (2003), Politics and the Environment: From Theory to Practice, London, Routledge. Politics and the Environment: From Theory to Practice Google Scholar

CORDY, T. (2002), Introductory Guide to Planning and Environmental Protection, London, Thomas Telford. Introductory Guide to Planning and Environmental Protection Google Scholar

COVEY, R. and LAFFOLEY, D. D'A. (2002), Maritime State of Nature Report for England: Getting Onto an Even Keel, Peterborough, English Nature. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

DEFRA (DEPARTMENT FOR ENVIRONMENT, FOOD AND RURAL AFFAIRS) (2001), Safeguarding Our Seas: A Strategy for the Conservation and Sustainable Development of Our Marine Environment, London, DEFRA. Google Scholar

DEFRA (DEPARTMENT FOR ENVIRONMENT, FOOD AND RURAL AFFAIRS) (2002), Seas of Change: Consultation Paper, London, DEFRA. Google Scholar

DIXON-GOUGH, R. W. (2001), 'Partnerships in European coastal zone management' in R. W. Dixon-Gough (ed.), European Coastal Management: Partnership Approaches, Aldershot, Ashgate, 1-17. Partnerships in European coastal zone management European Coastal Management: Partnership Approaches 1 17 Google Scholar

DOWNS, A. (1972), 'Up and down with ecology: the issue-attention cycle', The Public Interest, 28, 38-50. 'Up and down with ecology: the issue-attention cycle' The Public Interest 28 38 50 Google Scholar

DUNION, K. (2003), Troublemakers: The Struggle for Environmental Justice in Scotland, Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press. Troublemakers: The Struggle for Environmental Justice in Scotland Google Scholar

FALUDI, A. and WATERHOUT, B. (2002), The Making of the European Spatial Development Perspective: No Masterplan, London, Routledge. The Making of the European Spatial Development Perspective: No Masterplan Google Scholar

FIRN, J. and MCGLASHAN, D. (2001), A Coastal Management Trust for Scotland, Edinburgh, Scottish Executive Central Research Unit. Google Scholar

FRENCH, P. (1997), Coastal and Estuarine Management, London, Routledge. Coastal and Estuarine Management Google Scholar

GUBBAY, S. (1990), A Future for the Coast? Proposals for a UK Coastal Zone Management Plan, Ross-on-Wye, Marine Conservation Society. A Future for the Coast? Proposals for a UK Coastal Zone Management Plan Google Scholar

GUBBAY, S. (2001), The Role of Scottish Local Initiatives in Implementing the Principles of Integrated Coastal Zone Management, Edinburgh, Scottish Executive Central Research Unit. Google Scholar

HAJER, M. A. (1996), 'Ecological modernisation as cultural politics', in S. Lash, B. Szerszynski and B. Wynne (eds), Risk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology, London, Sage. Ecological modernisation as cultural politics Risk, Environment and Modernity: Towards a New Ecology Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

HANNIGAN, J. A. (1995), Environmental Sociology. A Social Constructionist Perspective, London, Routledge. Environmental Sociology. A Social Constructionist Perspective Google Scholar

HUMPHREY, S. and BURBRIDGE, P. (2003), 'Sectoral and territorial cooperation in the European Demonstration Programme on ICZM', Coastal Management, 31, 155-62. 'Sectoral and territorial cooperation in the European Demonstration Programme on ICZM' Coastal Management 31 155 62 Google Scholar

JOINT LINKS (2002), Marine Spatial Planning for the UK (Discussion Paper), London, Joint Links. Google Scholar

JOINT STATEMENT BY THE LEADERS OF THE SCOTTISH LABOUR PARTY AND THE SCOTTISH LIBERAL DEMOCRATS (2003), A Partnership for a Better Scotland: Partnership Agreement, > http:// www.scotland.gov.uk/library5/government/pfbs-01.asp Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

KAY, R. and ALDER, J. (1999), Coastal Planning and Management, London, EF&N Spon. Coastal Planning and Management Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

KIDD, S., MASSEY, D. and DAVIES, H. (2003), 'The ESDP and integrated coastal zone management: implications for the integrated management of the Irish Sea', Town Planning Review, 74, 97-120. 'The ESDP and integrated coastal zone management: implications for the integrated management of the Irish Sea' Town Planning Review 74 97 120 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

LAFFOLEY, D. D'A. (2000), Historical Perspective and Selective Review of the Literature on Human Impacts on the UK's Marine Environment (prepared by English Nature for the DETR Working Group on the Review of Marine Nature Conservation) (English Nature Research Report No. 391), Peterborough, English Nature. Google Scholar

LAFFOLEY, D. D'A., VINCENT, M., CONNOR, D. W., HILL, M. and BREEN, J. (2002), Strategic Goals and Objectives for Marine Nature Conservation and Associated Indicators (prepared by English Nature for the DETR Working Group on the Review of Marine Nature Conservation) (English Nature Research Report, No. 482), Peterborough, English Nature. Google Scholar

LEITMANN, J. (1998), 'Options for managing protected areas: lessons from international experience', Journal of Environmental Planning and Management, 41, 129-43. 'Options for managing protected areas: lessons from international experience' Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 41 129 43 Google Scholar

LITTLE, G. (2000), 'Scottish devolution and environmental law', Journal of Environmental Law, 12, 155-74. 'Scottish devolution and environmental law' Journal of Environmental Law 12 155 74 Google Scholar

LLOYD, M. G. (1998), 'Ebb and flow of policy: strategic planning for the Scottish coast', Environmental and Waste Management, 1, 125-30. 'Ebb and flow of policy: strategic planning for the Scottish coast' Environmental and Waste Management 1 125 30 Google Scholar

LLOYD, M. G. and PEEL, D. (2003), 'Shaping National Space in Scotland', Town and Country Planning, 72, 224-25. 'Shaping National Space in Scotland' Town and Country Planning 72 224 25 Google Scholar

LOWE, P. and WARD, S. (eds) (1998), British Environmental Policy and Europe, London, Routledge. British Environmental Policy and Europe Google Scholar

MAFF (MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, FISHERIES AND FOOD) (1995), Shoreline Management Plans: A Guide for Coastal Defence Authorities, London, MAFF. Google Scholar

MARINE CONSERVATION SOCIETY (2003), 'Everyone can help Scotland's Seas' (media release, 17 February), > www.everyonecan.org Google Scholar

MCGLASHAN D. J. and WILLIAMS, E. (2003), 'Stakeholder involvement in coastal decision making processes', Local Environment, 8, 85-94. 'Stakeholder involvement in coastal decision making processes' Local Environment 8 85 94 Google Scholar

MOSSBERGER, K. and WOLMAN, H. (2003), 'Policy transfer as a form of prospective policy evaluation: challenges and recommendations', Public Administration and Review, 63, 428-40. 'Policy transfer as a form of prospective policy evaluation: challenges and recommendations' Public Administration and Review 63 428 40 Google Scholar

MULLARD, S. (1994), Towards An EU Strategy for Integrated Coastal Zone Management (IEEP London Background Briefing Paper No. 1), London, Institute for European Environmental Policy. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

REID C. T. (1997), Environmental Law in Scotland, Edinburgh, W. Green. Environmental Law in Scotland Google Scholar

RICE, T., OWEN, P. and RICE, A. L. (1999), Decommissioning of Brent Spar, London, Routledge/ EF&N Spon. Decommissioning of Brent Spar Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

RYDIN, Y. (1998), Urban and Environmental Planning in the UK, London, Macmillan. Urban and Environmental Planning in the UK Google Scholar

SCOTTISH EXECUTIVE (2002), Assessment of the Effectiveness of Local Coastal Management Partnerships as a Delivery Mechanism for Integrated Coastal Zone Management (Social Research, Countryside and Natural Heritage, Research Findings 23), Edinburgh, Scottish Executive. Google Scholar

SMITH, M. D. (1991), 'The present and future of coastal zone management in the UK', Land Use Policy, 8,125-32. The present and future of coastal zone management in the UK Land Use Policy 8 125 32 Google Scholar

SOLESBURY, W. (2002), 'The ascendancy of evidence', Planning Theory and Practice, 3, 90-96. 'The ascendancy of evidence' Planning Theory and Practice 3 90 96 Google Scholar

STOKER, G. (1993), 'Coastal zone protection and planning', Journal of Planning and Environment Law, June, 521-26. Coastal zone protection and planning Journal of Planning and Environment Law, June 521 26 Google Scholar

SWCL (SCOTTISH WILDLIFE AND COUNTRYSIDE LINK) (1993), All at Sea: Coastal Zone Management: The Case for Scotland, Perth, SWCL. Google Scholar

TAUSSIK, J. (1997), 'The influence of institutional systems on planning the coastal zone: experience from England/Wales and Sweden', Planning Practice and Research, 12, 9-19. 'The influence of institutional systems on planning the coastal zone: experience from England/Wales and Sweden' Planning Practice and Research 12 9 19 Google Scholar

TAUSSIK, J. (2001), 'The contribution of town and country planning to the resolution of conflict in the coastal zone' in R. Dixon-Gough (ed.), European Coastal Management: Partnership Approach, Aldershot, Ashgate, 142-54. The contribution of town and country planning to the resolution of conflict in the coastal zone European Coastal Management: Partnership Approach 142 54 Google Scholar

TYLDESLEY, D. (2004), Making the Case for Marine Spatial Planning in Scotland, Edinburgh, RSPB Scotland and RTPI in Scotland. Making the Case for Marine Spatial Planning in Scotland Google Scholar

WARFORD, M. (1997), Greenpeace Witness: Twenty-Five Years on the Environmental Front Line, London, Andre Deutsch. Greenpeace Witness: Twenty-Five Years on the Environmental Front Line Google Scholar

WARREN, C. (2002), Managing Scotland's Environment, Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press. Managing Scotland's Environment Google Scholar

WWF (WORLD WILDLIFE FUND) (2000), 'UK sea life on red alert', 20 September, > http://www. wwf.org.uk/news/n_0000000133.asp Google Scholar

WWF (WORLD WILDLIFE FUND) (2003), 'Government failure trashes Scotland's great barrier reef, 23 April, > http://www.wwf.org.uk/news/scotland/n_0000000871.asp Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Peel, Deborah

Lloyd, M. Greg