International Development Planning Review

Beyond state regulation of informality: understanding access to public space by street vendors in Bogotá

International Development Planning Review (2019), 41, (1), 85–105.

Abstract

Selling goods and providing services in public spaces is one of the most accessible occupations for many urban poor. However, use of public space for such occupations is often prohibited by local regulations, excluding street vendors from legally using this space for their survival. While significant research has been devoted to state efforts to control informality, less is known about the everyday governance of street vendors. This article examines how unorganised street vendors regulate access to public space among themselves. We also analyse the contestation and negotiations between state and street vendors. The article is based on a study of street vendors in Bogotá, Colombia. We argue that informal street vendors do not operate in chaos, instead the ‘quiet encroachment’ of public space is governed by nonhierachical informal social control mechanisms. Our findings call for a reconsideration of regulations about urban informal activities and public spaces.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Adama, O. (2014) ‘Marginalisation and integration within the informal urban economy: the case of child waste pickers in Kaduna, Nigeria’, International Development Planning Review, 36(2), 155–80. Marginalisation and integration within the informal urban economy: the case of child waste pickers in Kaduna, Nigeria International Development Planning Review 36 155 80 Google Scholar

Alfonso, W. H. (2010) ‘Politización de las ventas ambulantes en Bogotá’, Revista de Arquitectura. 12(1), 4–16. Politización de las ventas ambulantes en Bogotá Revista de Arquitectura 12 4 16 Google Scholar

Anjaria, J. S. (2006) ‘Street hawkers and public space in Mumbai’, Economic and Political Weekly, 41(2), 2140–46. Street hawkers and public space in Mumbai Economic and Political Weekly 41 2140 46 Google Scholar

Arosanyin, G. T., Olowosulu, A. T. and Oyeyemi, G. M. (2011) ‘Employment generation and earnings in the informal transport sector in Nigeria’, International Business and Management, 2(2), 139–48. Employment generation and earnings in the informal transport sector in Nigeria International Business and Management 2 139 48 Google Scholar

Austin, R. (1993) ‘Honest living: street vendors, municipal regulation, and the black public sphere’, The Yale Law Journal, 103(8), 2119–31. Honest living: street vendors, municipal regulation, and the black public sphere The Yale Law Journal 103 2119 31 Google Scholar

Banik, D. (2011) The legal empowerment agenda: poverty, labour and the informal economy in Africa, Ashgate, Routledge. The legal empowerment agenda: poverty, labour and the informal economy in Africa Google Scholar

Batréau, Q. and Bonnet, F. (2016) ‘Managed informality: regulating street vendors in Bangkok’, City & Community, 15(1), 29–43. Managed informality: regulating street vendors in Bangkok City & Community 15 29 43 Google Scholar

Bayat, A. (2000) ‘From “dangerous classes” to “quiet rebels”: politics of the urban subaltern in the global South’, International Sociology, 15(3), 533–57. From “dangerous classes” to “quiet rebels”: politics of the urban subaltern in the global South International Sociology 15 533 57 Google Scholar

Bhowmik, S. K. (2010) ‘Legal protection for street vendors’, Economic and Political Weekly, 45(51), 12–15. Legal protection for street vendors Economic and Political Weekly 45 12 15 Google Scholar

Bromley, R. (2000) ‘Street vending and public policy: a global review’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(1–2), 1–28. Street vending and public policy: a global review International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 20 1 28 Google Scholar

Bromley, R. and Wilson, T. D. (2018) ‘Introduction: the urban informal economy revisited’, Latin American Perspectives, 45(1), 4–23. Introduction: the urban informal economy revisited Latin American Perspectives 45 4 23 Google Scholar

Brown, A. (2015) ‘Claiming the streets: property rights and legal empowerment in the urban informal economy’, World Development, 76, 238–48. Claiming the streets: property rights and legal empowerment in the urban informal economy World Development 76 238 48 Google Scholar

Brown, A., Lyons, M. and Dankoco, I. (2010) ‘Street traders and the emerging spaces for urban voice and citizenship in African cities’, Urban Studies, 47(3), 666–83. Street traders and the emerging spaces for urban voice and citizenship in African cities Urban Studies 47 666 83 Google Scholar

Carbonell, C. M. (2013) ‘El sector de San Victorino en los procesos de reconfiguración urbana de Bogotá (1598–1998)’, Cuadernos de Vivienda y Urbanismo, 3(6), 220–45. El sector de San Victorino en los procesos de reconfiguración urbana de Bogotá (1598–1998) Cuadernos de Vivienda y Urbanismo 3 220 45 Google Scholar

Castán Broto, V. and Neves Alves, S. (2018) ‘Intersectionality challenges for the co-production of urban services: notes for a theoretical and methodological agenda’, Environment & Urbanization, 30(2), 367–86. Intersectionality challenges for the co-production of urban services: notes for a theoretical and methodological agenda Environment & Urbanization 30 367 86 Google Scholar

Chen, M. A., Jhabvala, R. and Lund, F. (2002) Supporting workers in the informal economy: a policy framework, Geneva, International Labour Organization. Supporting workers in the informal economy: a policy framework Google Scholar

CLEP (Commission on Legal Empowerment of the Poor) (2008) Making the law work for everyone, New York, CLEP and UN. Google Scholar

Cross, J. (1998) Informal politics: street vendors and the state in Mexico City, Stanford, Stanford University Press. Informal politics: street vendors and the state in Mexico City Google Scholar

Cross, J. (2000) ‘Street vendors, and postmodernity: conflict and compromise in the global economy’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(1–2), 29–51. Street vendors, and postmodernity: conflict and compromise in the global economy International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 20 29 51 Google Scholar

Crossa, C. (2009) ‘Resisting the entrepreneurial city: street vendors’ struggle in Mexico City’s historic center’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 33(1), 43–63. Resisting the entrepreneurial city: street vendors’ struggle in Mexico City’s historic center International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 33 43 63 Google Scholar

Crossa, C. (2015) ‘Creative resistance: the case of Mexico City’s street artisans and vendors’, in K. Graaff and N. Ha (eds) Street vending in the neoliberal city: a global perspective on the practices and policies of a marginalized economy, New York and Oxford, Berghahn, 59–78. Creative resistance: the case of Mexico City’s street artisans and vendors Street vending in the neoliberal city: a global perspective on the practices and policies of a marginalized economy 59 78 Google Scholar

DANE (2018) Proyecciones de población 2005–2020, Bogotá, D.A.N. de E. Google Scholar

De Soto, H. (1989) The other path: the invisible revolution in the Third World, Tauris, London. The other path: the invisible revolution in the Third World Google Scholar

Donovan, M. (2002) ‘Space wars in Bogotá: the recovery of public space and its impact on street vendors’, MA thesis, Cambridge, MA, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Space wars in Bogotá: the recovery of public space and its impact on street vendors Google Scholar

Donovan, M. (2008) ‘Informal cities and the contestation of public space: the case of Bogotá’s street vendors, 1988–2003’, Urban Studies, 45(1), 29–51. Informal cities and the contestation of public space: the case of Bogotá’s street vendors, 1988–2003 Urban Studies 45 29 51 Google Scholar

Ehrenfeucht, R. (2016) ‘Designing fair and effective street vending policy: it’s time for a new approach’, Cityscape, 18(1), 11–26. Designing fair and effective street vending policy: it’s time for a new approach Cityscape 18 11 26 Google Scholar

Ellickson, R. C. (1991) Order without law: how neighbors settle disputes, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press. Order without law: how neighbors settle disputes Google Scholar

Etzold, B. (2013) The politics of street food. contested governance and vulnerabilities in Dhaka’s field of street vending, Stuttgart, Franz Steiner Verlag. The politics of street food. contested governance and vulnerabilities in Dhaka’s field of street vending Google Scholar

Faundez, J. (2009) ‘Empowering workers in the informal economy’, Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, 1(1), 156–72. Empowering workers in the informal economy Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 1 156 72 Google Scholar

Ferragut, S. and Gómez, G. M. (2013) ‘From the street to the store: the formalization of street vendors in Quito, Ecuador’, in I. Hillenkamp, F. Lapeyre and A. Lemaitre (eds) Securing livelihoods: informal economy practices and institutions, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 214–34. From the street to the store: the formalization of street vendors in Quito, Ecuador Securing livelihoods: informal economy practices and institutions 214 34 Google Scholar

Flock, R. and Breitung, W. (2015) ‘Migrant street vendors in urban China and the social production of public space’, Population, Space and Place, 22(2), 158–69. Migrant street vendors in urban China and the social production of public space Population, Space and Place 22 158 69 Google Scholar

Gillespie, T. (2017) ‘From quiet to bold encroachment: contesting dispossession in Accra’s informal sector’, Urban Geography, 38(7), 974–92. From quiet to bold encroachment: contesting dispossession in Accra’s informal sector Urban Geography 38 974 92 Google Scholar

Grünenfelder, J. and Schurr, C. (2015) ‘Intersectionality: a challenge for development research and practice?’, Development in Practice, 25(6), 771–84. Intersectionality: a challenge for development research and practice? Development in Practice 25 771 84 Google Scholar

Hansen, K. T. (2010) ‘Changing youth dynamics in Lusaka’s informal economy in the context of economic liberalization’, African Studies Quarterly, 11(2–3), 13–27. Changing youth dynamics in Lusaka’s informal economy in the context of economic liberalization African Studies Quarterly 11 13 27 Google Scholar

Hanser, A. (2016) ‘Street politics: street vendors and urban governance in China’, The China Quarterly, 226, 363–82. Street politics: street vendors and urban governance in China The China Quarterly 226 363 82 Google Scholar

Hawkins, D. (2011) The struggles over city-space: informal street vending and public space governance in Medellin, Colombia, Baden-Baden, Nomos Publishers. The struggles over city-space: informal street vending and public space governance in Medellin, Colombia Google Scholar

Huang, G., Xue, D. and Li, Z. (2014) ‘From revanchism to ambivalence: the changing politics of street vending in Guangzhou’, Antipode, 46(1), 170–89. From revanchism to ambivalence: the changing politics of street vending in Guangzhou Antipode 46 170 89 Google Scholar

Hunt, S. (2009) ‘Citizenship’s place: the state’s creation of public space and street vendors’ culture of informality in Bogotá, Colombia’, Environment and Planning D, 27(2), 331–51. Citizenship’s place: the state’s creation of public space and street vendors’ culture of informality in Bogotá, Colombia Environment and Planning D 27 331 51 Google Scholar

IPES (2016) Caracterización vendedores informales en Bogotá, Bogotá, I.P. la E.S. Google Scholar

Lara, A. E. H. (2009) ‘La discriminación institucional de vendedoras ambulantes: los retos de una “pobre” madre pobre trabajando en la calle’, Revista Pueblos y Fronteras Digital, 5(8), 237–63. La discriminación institucional de vendedoras ambulantes: los retos de una “pobre” madre pobre trabajando en la calle Revista Pueblos y Fronteras Digital 5 237 63 Google Scholar

Linares, L. A. (2018) ‘The paradoxes of informalizing street trade in the Latin American city’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 38(7–8), 651–72. The paradoxes of informalizing street trade in the Latin American city International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 38 651 72 Google Scholar

Lindell, I. (2008) ‘The multiple sites of urban governance: insights from an African city’, Urban Studies, 45(9), 1879–1901. The multiple sites of urban governance: insights from an African city Urban Studies 45 1879 1901 Google Scholar

Lindell, I., Hedman, M. and Nathan-Verboomen, K. (2010) The World Cup 2010 and the urban poor: ‘world class cities’ for all?, Uppsala, Nordic Africa Institute. The World Cup 2010 and the urban poor: ‘world class cities’ for all? Google Scholar

Meneses-Reyes, R. (2013) ‘Out of place, still in motion: shaping (im)mobility through urban regulation’, Social & Legal Studies, 22(3), 335–56. Out of place, still in motion: shaping (im)mobility through urban regulation Social & Legal Studies 22 335 56 Google Scholar

Meza, A. (2003) ‘Trayectorias de los Afrodescendientes en el de Bogotá’, Revista Colombiana de Antropologia, 39, 71–104. Trayectorias de los Afrodescendientes en el de Bogotá Revista Colombiana de Antropologia 39 71 104 Google Scholar

Pádua Carrieri, A. and Murta, I. B. D. (2011) ‘Cleaning up the city: a study on the removal of street vendors from downtown Belo Horizonte, Brazil’, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 28(2), 217–25. Cleaning up the city: a study on the removal of street vendors from downtown Belo Horizonte, Brazil Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences 28 217 25 Google Scholar

Parker, S. (2004) Urban theory and the urban experience: encountering the city, Routledge, London. Urban theory and the urban experience: encountering the city Google Scholar

Parra, Ó. (2006) ‘De la ciudadanía autoritaria a una ciudadanía social diferenciada y participativa. Apuntes sobre el debate vendedores ambulantes-espacio público’, Estudio Políticos, 28, 31–59. De la ciudadanía autoritaria a una ciudadanía social diferenciada y participativa. Apuntes sobre el debate vendedores ambulantes-espacio público Estudio Políticos 28 31 59 Google Scholar

Pena, S. (2000) ‘Regulating informal markets: informal commerce in Mexico City’, International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy, 20(9–10), 37–67. Regulating informal markets: informal commerce in Mexico City International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy 20 37 67 Google Scholar

Perelman, M. (2013) ‘Formas sociales de estabilización en actividades informales. Cirujas y vendedores ambulantes en la ciudad de Buenos Aires’, Lavboratorio: Revista de Estudio sobre Cambio Social, 25, 37–55. Formas sociales de estabilización en actividades informales. Cirujas y vendedores ambulantes en la ciudad de Buenos Aires Lavboratorio: Revista de Estudio sobre Cambio Social 25 37 55 Google Scholar

Porter, L. (2011) ‘Informality, the commons and the paradoxes for planning: concepts and debates for informality and planning’, Planning, Theory and Practice, 12(1), 115–20. Informality, the commons and the paradoxes for planning: concepts and debates for informality and planning Planning, Theory and Practice 12 115 20 Google Scholar

Portes, A. and Landolt, P. (2000) ‘Social capital: promise and pitfalls of its role in development’, Journal of Latin and American Studies, 32(2), 529–47. Social capital: promise and pitfalls of its role in development Journal of Latin and American Studies 32 529 47 Google Scholar

Reiss, A. J. (1951) ‘Delinquency as the failure of personal and social controls’, American Sociological Review, 16(2), 196–207. Delinquency as the failure of personal and social controls American Sociological Review 16 196 207 Google Scholar

Roever, S. (2007) ‘Informal governance and organizational success: the effects of non-compliance among Lima’s street vending organizations’, in M. Chen, R. Jhabvala, R. Kanbur and C. Richards (eds) Membership based organizations of the poor, Abingdon, Routledge, 261–78. Informal governance and organizational success: the effects of non-compliance among Lima’s street vending organizations Membership based organizations of the poor 261 78 Google Scholar

Roever, S. (2016) ‘Informal trade meets informal governance: street vendors and legal reform in India, South Africa and Peru’, Cityscape: A Journal of Policy and Development and Research, 18(1), 27–46. Informal trade meets informal governance: street vendors and legal reform in India, South Africa and Peru Cityscape: A Journal of Policy and Development and Research 18 27 46 Google Scholar

Roy, A. (2005) ‘Urban informality: toward an epistemology of planning’, Journal of the American Planning Association, 71(2), 147–58. Urban informality: toward an epistemology of planning Journal of the American Planning Association 71 147 58 Google Scholar

Scarnecchia, A. and Cavagnoud, R. (2013) ‘Los chicos lustra calzados de La Paz: el uso del pasamontañas como forma de máscara y símbolo de identidad’, Bulletin de l’Institut français d’études andines, 42(3), 491–503. Los chicos lustra calzados de La Paz: el uso del pasamontañas como forma de máscara y símbolo de identidad Bulletin de l’Institut français d’études andines 42 491 503 Google Scholar

Schindler, S. (2014a) ‘Producing and contesting the formal/informal divide: regulating street hawking in Delhi, India’, Urban Studies, 51(12), 2596–612. Producing and contesting the formal/informal divide: regulating street hawking in Delhi, India Urban Studies 51 2596 612 Google Scholar

Schindler, S. (2014b) ‘A New Delhi every day: multiplicities of governance regimes in a transforming metropolis’, Urban Geography, 35(3), 402–19. A New Delhi every day: multiplicities of governance regimes in a transforming metropolis Urban Geography 35 402 19 Google Scholar

Sepulveda, L. and Syrett, S. (2007) ‘Out of the shadows? Formalisation approaches to informal economic activity’, Policy and Politics, 35(1), 87–104. Out of the shadows? Formalisation approaches to informal economic activity Policy and Politics 35 87 104 Google Scholar

Skinner, C. (2000) Securing livelihoods: a gendered analysis of support interventions available to street traders in the Durban Metropolitan Area, School of Development Studies (incorporating CSDS), Durban, University of Natal. Securing livelihoods: a gendered analysis of support interventions available to street traders in the Durban Metropolitan Area Google Scholar

Slocum, S. L., Backman, K. F. and Robinson, K. L. (2011) ‘Tourism pathways to prosperity: perspectives on the informal economy in Tanzania’, Tourism Analysis, 16(1), 43–55. Tourism pathways to prosperity: perspectives on the informal economy in Tanzania Tourism Analysis 16 43 55 Google Scholar

Song, L. (2016) ‘Planning with urban informality: a case for inclusion, co-production and reiteration’, International Development Planning Review, 38(4), 359–81. Planning with urban informality: a case for inclusion, co-production and reiteration International Development Planning Review 38 359 81 Google Scholar

Steel, G. (2012) ‘Whose paradise? Itinerant street vendors’ individual and collective practices of political agency in the tourist streets of Cusco, Peru’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 36(5), 1007–21. Whose paradise? Itinerant street vendors’ individual and collective practices of political agency in the tourist streets of Cusco, Peru International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 36 1007 21 Google Scholar

Swanson, K. (2007) ‘Revanchist urbanism heads South: the regulation of indigenous beggers and street vendors in Ecuador’, Antipode, 39(4), 708–28. Revanchist urbanism heads South: the regulation of indigenous beggers and street vendors in Ecuador Antipode 39 708 28 Google Scholar

Swanson, K. (2013) ‘Zero tolerance in Latin America: punitive paradox in urban policy mobilities’, Urban Geography, 34(7), 972–88. Zero tolerance in Latin America: punitive paradox in urban policy mobilities Urban Geography 34 972 88 Google Scholar

Turner, S. and Schoenberger, L. (2012) ‘Street vendor livelihoods and everyday politics in Hanoi, Vietnam: the seeds of a diverse economy’, Urban Studies, 49(5), 1027–44. Street vendor livelihoods and everyday politics in Hanoi, Vietnam: the seeds of a diverse economy Urban Studies 49 1027 44 Google Scholar

UN (United Nations) (2015) Transforming our world: the 2030 agenda for sustainable development, United Nations, http://www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=A/RES/70/1&Lang=E (accessed 10 July 2017). Google Scholar

Valverde, M. (2012) Everyday law on the street: city governance in an age of diversity, Chicago and London, University of Chicago Press. Everyday law on the street: city governance in an age of diversity Google Scholar

Vargas, A. M. (2017) ‘Formalizing street vendors: regulating to improve well-being or to gain control?’, in C. Fenwick (ed.) Regulating for equitable and job-rich growth, Cheltenham, Elgar, 195–213. Formalizing street vendors: regulating to improve well-being or to gain control? Regulating for equitable and job-rich growth 195 213 Google Scholar

Vargas, A. M. and Urinboyev, R. (2015) Everyday forms of resistance to the law: an ethnographic study of street vendors in Bogotá, Colombia, Droit Société. Everyday forms of resistance to the law: an ethnographic study of street vendors in Bogotá Google Scholar

Webb, J. W., Tihanyi, L., Ireland, R. D. and Sirmon, D. G. (2009) ‘You say illegal, I say legitimate: entrepreneurship in the informal economy’, Academy of Management Review, 34(3), 492–510. You say illegal, I say legitimate: entrepreneurship in the informal economy Academy of Management Review 34 492 510 Google Scholar

Xue, D. and Huang, G. (2015) ‘Informality and the state’s ambivalence in the regulation of street vending in transforming Guangzhou, China’, Geoforum, 62, 156–65. Informality and the state’s ambivalence in the regulation of street vending in transforming Guangzhou, China Geoforum 62 156 65 Google Scholar

Yatmo, Y. A. (2008) ‘Street vendors as “out of place” urban elements’, Journal of Urban Design, 13(3), 387–402. Street vendors as “out of place” urban elements Journal of Urban Design 13 387 402 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Falla, Ana Maria Vargas

Valencia, Sandra C.