Labour History

Recent Developments in Japanese Labour History

Labour History (2014), 107, (1), 211–220.

Abstract

There have been remarkable changes in Japanese labour history since the 1990s, especially since the beginning of the twenty-first century. First, there has been a shift in subject matter and themes studied. The most striking progress in the last decade has been in historical studies of white-collar workers and female workers in the silk-reeling industry. Second, there has been a diversification in the academic disciplines dealing with labour history. Third, notwithstanding the disciplinary diversification, labour organisation and institution have continued to attract growing interest. To understand such changes, this paper first takes up Andrew Gordon’s epoch-making work which appeared in 1985, and described in detail the century-long development of the “Japanese employment system.” However, while much attention is paid to the issues of “power and conflict,” blind spots remain. Second, drawing on my own recent work on new frontiers in the history of the “Japanese employment system,” the paper offers insights on problems that cannot be explained by the “power and conflict” theory approach. Third, the paper surveys major works on Japanese labour history over the last decade and clarifies that a recent trend in this field is reflected not only in the themes taken up in my work, but also in the explanatory approach adopted.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

 Google Scholar

Footnotes

1.Andrew Gordon, The Evolution of Labor Relations in Japan: Heavy Industry, 1853–1985(:Council on East Asian Studies, Harvard University Press, 1985). Google Scholar

2.Kazuo Nimura, Ashio Bōdō no Shiteki Bunseki: Kōzan Rōdōsha no Shakai-shi(A Historical Analysis of the Ashio Riot: A Social History of Mine Workers)(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 1988);Kazuo Nimura, The Ashio Riot of 1907: A Social History of Mining, ed.Andrew Gordon, trans.Terry Boardman andAndrew Gordon(:Duke University Press, 1997). Google Scholar

3.Gordon, Evolution of Labor Relations, 1. Google Scholar

4.Ronald Dore, British Factory, Japanese Factory: The Origins of National Diversity in Industrial Relations(:University of California Press, 1973). Google Scholar

5.Kazuo Koike, “Internal Labor Markets: Workers in Large Firms,”inContemporary Industrial Relations in Japan, ed.Taishiro Shirai(:University of Wisconsin Press, 1983). Google Scholar

6.Gordon, Evolution of Labor Relations, 2. Google Scholar

7.Dore, British Factory, Japanese Factory, 264–65. Google Scholar

8.Gordon, Evolution of Labor Relations, 5. Google Scholar

9.Tsutomu Hyodo, Nihon ni okeru Rōshi Kankei no Tenkai(The Development of Labor-Capital Relations in Japan)(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 1971). Google Scholar

10.Koike, “Internal Labor Markets.” Google Scholar

11.Shinji Sugayama, “Shū-ska” Shakai no Tanjō: Howaito-Karā kara Burū-Karā e(The Birth of the“Shūsha”Society: From White-Collar Employees to Blue-Collar Workers)(:Nagoya Daigaku Shuppankai, 2011). The“shū-ska”society in the original Japanese title refers to the social construct in which graduates begin their careers upon graduation and remain with their companies until retirement age. Google Scholar

12.Shinji Sugayama, “Work Rules, Wages, and Single Status: The Shaping of the ‘Japanese Employment System,’” Business History 37, no. 2(1995):120–40. Google Scholar

13.Takehiko Kariya, Gakkō, Shokugyō, Senbatsu no Shakaigaku(A Sociology of Schools, Occupations, and Selection)(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 1991). Google Scholar

14.Sugayama, The Birth of “Shū-sha” Society, 168. Google Scholar

15.Hoshimi Uchida, “Gijutsusha no Zōka Bunpu to Nihon no Kōgyō-ka” (The Increase and Distribution of Highly-Educated Engineers and Japan’s Industriarisatoin), Keizai Kenkyū 39, no. 4(1988):289–97. Google Scholar

16.Yō Nakanishi, Nihon Kindai-ka no Kiso Katei: Nagasaki Zōsenjo to sono Rōshi Kankei(The Fundamental Processes of Japan’s Modernisation: Nagasaki Shipyard and its Labour-Capital Relations) vols 1–2(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 1984–85);Shin’ichi Yonekawa, “Meijiki Dai Bōseki Kigyō no Shokuin-sō” (White-Collar Employees of Large Firms in the Cotton Spinning Industry in the Meiji Era), Shakai Keizai Shigaku 51, no. 4(1985):421–54;Shinji Sugayama, “1920 Nendai Jū-Denki Keiei no Kakyū Shokuin-sō: Hitachi Seisakusho no Jirei Bunseki” (Middle and Lower Stratum of White-Collar Employees in the Electrical Machinery Industry in the 1920s: A Case Study of Hitachi Ltd.), Shakai Keizai Shigaku 53, no. 5(1987):661–96. Google Scholar

17.Shinji Sugayama, “Business Education, Training, and the Emergence of the ‘Japanese Employment System,’”inEducation and Training in the Development of Modern Corporations, ed.Nobuo Kawabe andEisuke Daitō(:University of Tokyo Press, 1993), 147–71;Naofumi Nakamura, Nihon Tetsudōgyō no Keisei(The Formation of Japanese Railway Industry)(:Nihon Keizai Hyōronsha, 1998);Jonwon U, “Mibun no Torihiki” to Nihon no Koyō Kankō: Kokutetsu no Jirei Bunseki(“Transaction of Status” and Employment Practices in Japan: A Case Study of National Railway)(:Nihon Keizai Hyōronsha, 2002);Mitsuru Yamashita, Kōsaku Kikai Sangyō no Shokuba-shi, 1889–1945(A History of Engineers on the Shop Floor in the Machine Tool Industry, 1889–1945)(:Waseda Daigaku Shuppanbu, 2002);Yō Nakanishi, Nihon Kindai-ka no Kiso Katei: Nagasaki Zōsenjo to sono Rōshi Kankei(The Fundamental Processes of Japan’s Modernisation: Nagasaki Shipyard and its Labour-Capital Relations) vol. 3(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 2003);Tetsuji Okazaki, “Senzenki Mitsubishi Zaibatsu no Naibu Rōdō Shijō” (Internal Labour Market of Mitsubishi Zaibatsu in the Prewar Period), Mitsubishi Shiryōkan Ronshū 6(2005):133–64;Hiroshi Ichihara, “Senzenki Mitsubishi Denki no Gijutsu Kaihatsu to Gijutsusha” (Technical Development and Engineers of Mitsubishi Electric Co. in the Prewar Period), Keiei Shigaku 41, no.4(2007):3–26;Shinji Sugayama, “The Evolution of Regular Hiring of New Graduates in Japan,” Japanese Research on Business History 28(2011):61–83;Minoru Sawai, Kindai Ōsaka no Kōgyō Kyōiku(Technical Education of Modern Ōsaka)(:Ōsaka Daigaku Shuppankai, 2012). Google Scholar

18.Makoto Kasuya, “Continuity and Change in the Employment and Promotion of Japanese White-Collar Employees: The Case of the House of Mitsui,” Enterprise & Society 6, no. 2(2005)224–53;Yukio Wakabayashi, Mitsui Bussan Jinji Seisaku-shi 1876–1931(A History of Personnel Management of Mitsui & Co. 1876–1931)(:Minerva Shobō, 2007). Google Scholar

19.Masaki Nakabayashi, Kindai Shihonshugi no Soshiki: Seishigyō no Hatten ni okeru Torihiki no Tōchi to Seisan no Kōzō(An Organization of Modern Capitalism: The Governance of Trade and the System of Production in the Development of the Silk-Reeling Industry)(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 2003). Google Scholar

20.Masaki Nakabayashi, “The Rise of a Factory Industry: Silk Reeling in Suwa,”inThe Role of Tradition in Japan’s Industrialization, ed.Masayuki Tanimoto(:Oxford University Press, 2006), 201. Google Scholar

21.Ryō Kambayashi, “Chingin Seido to Rishoku Kōdō: Meiji Kōki no Suwa-chihō no Seishi no Rei” (Wage System and Activity of Leaving Jobs: A Case in Silk Reeling in Suwa District in the Late Meiji Era), inTorihiki Seido no Keizai-shi(Governing Business Transactions: A Historical Perspective), ed.Tetsuji Okazaki(:Tokyo Daigaku Shuppankai, 2003), 161–235. Google Scholar

22.Yukihiko Kiyokawa, Kindai Seishi Gijutsu to Ajia: Gijutsu Dōnyū no Hikaku Keizai-shi(Modern Silk-Reeling Technology and Asia: A Comparative Economic History of Introduction of Technology)(:Nagoya Daigaku Shuppankai, 2009). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Sugayama, Shinji