Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History

‘You really only made it because you needed the money’: Aboriginal Women and Shellwork Production, 1870s to 1970s

Labour History: A Journal of Labour and Social History (2011), 101, (1), 71–89.

Abstract

For almost 150 years, Aboriginal women around Sydney have engaged in an informal cash economy by making and selling small shell-decorated objects. The longevity of the practice, which spans the period from the 1870s to the present, provides a rare opportunity to present a detailed historical case study of aspects of Aboriginal women’s work in settled Australia. This discussion pays careful attention to the changing contexts within which these commodities were made and sold, along with Aboriginal women’s responses to new and changed conditions in ways that sought to sustain this valued economic activity. The approach used in this article combines interpretation of archival, pictorial and oral history sources about markets and makers with analysis of the objects themselves.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Endnotes

1.See, for instance,D. May, Aboriginal Labour and the Cattle Industry: Queensland from White Settlement to the Present,Cambridge University Press, 1994;A. McGrath, Born in the Cattle: Aborigines in the Cattle Industry,Allen & Unwin,, 1987;H. Reynolds, With the White People,Penguin,, 1990;B. Morris, ‘From underemployment to unemployment: The changing role of Aborigines in a rural economy’, Mankind, vol.13, no.6, 1983, pp.499-516;A. Cole, ‘Taking female subordination for granted: Aboriginal women’s labour and the concept of underemployment’, inP. Hetherington andP. Maddern(eds), Sexuality and Gender in History: Selected Essays,Centre for Western Australian History,, 1993, pp.63-77;J. Beckett, Torres Strait Islanders: Custom and Colonialism,Cambridge University Press,, 1987;S. Robinson, Something Like Slavery? Queensland’s Aboriginal Child Workers, 1842-1945,Australian Scholarly Publishing,, 2008;V. Haskins, ‘& so we are “slave owners”!’: Employers and the NSW Aborigines Protection Board Trust Funds, Labour History, no.88, May2005, pp.147-64;A. McGrath, A. andSaunders, K. withJackie Huggins(eds), Aboriginal Workers,Australian Society for the Study of Labour History,, 1995;A. Curthoys andC. Moore, ‘Working for the white people: An historiographic essay on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander labour’, inAboriginal Workers, pp.1-29. Google Scholar

2.See, for instance,J. Altman andL. Taylor(eds), Marketing Aboriginal Art in the 1990s,Aboriginal Studies Press,, 1990;N. Williams, ‘Australian Aboriginal art at Yirrkala: Introduction and development of marketing’, inN. Graburn(ed.), Ethnic and Tourist Arts: Cultural Expressions from the Fourth World,University of California Press,, 1976, pp.266-84;H. Morphy, Becoming Art: Exploring Cross-cultural Categories,Berg,, 2007. Google Scholar

3.Reproduced inM. Henderson andE. Wilkinson, Whatnot: A Compendium of Victorian Crafts and Other Matters … Assembled from the Original 19th Century Edition of Cassell’s Household Guide,William Morrow and Co.,, 1977, p.53. Google Scholar

4.B. Beller, ‘Shellwork’, in Individual Heritage Group, La Perouse: The Place, the People and the Sea,Aboriginal Studies Press,, 1988, p.80. Google Scholar

5.S. Kleinert, ‘Writing craft/writing history’, Humanities Research, no.1, 2000, pp.77-96;S. Kleinert, ‘Jacky Jacky was a Smart Young Fella’: A Study of Art and Aboriginality in South East Australia 1900-1980, PhD thesis,Australian National University, 1994, esp. ch. 5;D. Barwick, ‘Coranderrk and Cumeroogunga: Pioneers and policy’, inT.S. Epstein andD.H. Penny(eds), Opportunity and Response: Case Studies in Economic Development,C. Hurst,, 1972, pp.11-68;D. Barwick, ‘And the lubras are ladies now’, inF. Gale(ed.), Woman’s Role in Aboriginal Society,Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies,, 2nd edn, 1974, pp.51-63. Google Scholar

6.See for instance: Trustees of the Museum of Applied Arts and Sciences, Australian Communities,Powerhouse Museum,, 1991, pp.6-8;M. Neale, Yiribana: An Introduction to the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Collection in the Art Gallery of New South Wales,Art Gallery of New South Wales,, 1994. Google Scholar

7.S. Kleinert, ‘Writing craft/writing history’;Ruth B. Phillips, Trading Identities: The Souvenir in Native North American Art from the Northeast, 1700-1900,University of Washington Press/McGill-Queen’s University Press, 1998. Google Scholar

8.A. Stephen, ‘Jane Simms and Olive Simms’, inJ. Kerr(ed.), Heritage: The National Women’s Art Book: 500 Works by 500 Australian Women Artists from Colonial Times to 1955,Craftsman House,, 1995. Google Scholar

9.Individual Heritage Group, La Perouse;M. Nugent, La Perouse: A Postcolonial History, PhD thesis,University of Technology,, 2000. Google Scholar

10.I. Vanni, ‘Bridging the gap: The production of tourist objects at La Perouse’, inS. Kleinert andM. Neale(eds), Oxford Companion to Aboriginal Art and Culture,Oxford University Press,, 2000, pp.400-402;A. Stephen, ‘Jane and Olive Simms’, Design and Art Australia Online(DAAO),http://www.daao.org.au/main/read/5749, accessed 17 March 2011;T. Allas, ‘Esme Timbery’, DAAO,http://www.daao.org.au/main/read/6173, accessed 17 March 2011;M. Nugent, Botany Bay: Where Histories Meet,Allen & Unwin, 2005, pp.81-83;M. Nugent, ‘Emma Timbery’, DAAO,http://www.daao.org.au/main/read/7532, accessed 17 March 2011. Google Scholar

11.K. Martin(director), She Sells Seashells[videorecording],Australian Broadcasting Corporation,, 2007;T. Allas, ‘Esme Timbery’, Art Monthly Australia, no.187, March2006, pp.24-26. Google Scholar

12.Art Gallery of NSW, La Per: An Aboriginal Seaside Story[exhibition],http://www.artgallery.nsw.gov.au/exhibitions/la-per/accessed 21 July 2011. The National Gallery of Australia sells contemporary La Perouse shellwork in its shop. Google Scholar

13.A. Appadurai, ‘Introduction: Commodities and the politics of value’, inA. Appadurai(ed.), The Social Life of Things: Commodities in Cultural Perspective,Cambridge University Press,, 1986(reprint 2005), pp.3-63. Google Scholar

14.See for instance:D. Nash, ‘From shell work to shell art: Koori women creating knowledge and value on the South Coast of NSW’, craft + design enquiry, vol.2, 2010, pp.1-37;Vanni, ‘Bridging the gap’;Allas, ‘Esme Timbery’;J. Mendelssohn, ‘The secret magical hybrid life of us’, New Matilda, 1September2004,http://newmatilda.com/2004/09/01/secret-magical-hybrid-life-us, accessed 17 March 2011. For a similar interpretation of Aboriginal women collecting and selling wildflowers, seeH. Goodall andA. Cadzow, Rivers and Resilience: Aboriginal People on Sydney’s Georges River,University of NSW Press,, 2009. Google Scholar

15.SeeBarwick, ‘And the lubras are ladies now’;M. West, ‘Strings through the heart’, inReCoil: Change and Exchange in Coiled Fibre Art,Artback Northern Territory Arts Touring,, 2007, pp.13-27;J. Gough, ‘Lola Greeno’, DAAO,http://www.daao.org.au/main/read/7135, accessed 18 March 2011;‘An unbroken strand: Palawa shell necklaces’, inFloating Life: Contemporary Aboriginal Fibre Art,Queensland Art Gallery,, 2009. Google Scholar

16.See for instance:Leisure Hour Work for Ladies: Containing Instructions for Flower and Shell Work, Antique, Grecian and Theorem Painting,Frank M. Reed,, 1875;C.S. Jones andH.T. Williams, Ladies’ Fancy Work: Hints and Helps to Home Taste and Recreations,Sampson Low and Co.,, 1876;Cassell’s Household Guide: Being a Complete Encyclopaedia of Domestic and Social Economy,Cassell, Petter and Galpin,, c.1869-71.Cassell’s Household Guideincluded instructions and patterns for making shellwork baskets, boxes and flowers. Some are reproduced in Henderson and Wilkinson, Whatnot. Google Scholar

17.Henderson and Wilkinson, Whatnot, pp.53-62. Google Scholar

18.P. McKenzie andA. Stephen, ‘La Perouse: An urban Aboriginal community’, inM. Kelly(ed.), Sydney: City of Suburbs,University of NSW Press in association with the Sydney History Group,, 1987, p.179. See alsoJ. Isaacs, The Gentle Arts: 200 Years of Australian Women’s Domestic and Decorative Arts,, 1987, pp.166-67. Google Scholar

19.Phillips, Trading Identities, esp. ch. 6. Google Scholar

20.J. Toller, The Regency and Victorian Crafts, or The Genteel Female: Her Arts and Pursuits,Ward Lock,, 1969;G. Cochrane, The Craft’s Movement in Australia: A History,University of NSW Press,, 1992. Google Scholar

21.N. Thomas, Entangled Objects: Exchange, Material Culture and Colonialism in the Pacific,Harvard University Press,, 1991. See alsoP. Jones, Ochre and Rust: Artefacts and Encounters on Australian Frontiers,Wakefield Press,, 2007;J. Clifford, The Predicament of Culture: Twentieth-century Ethnography, Literature and Art,Harvard University Press,, 1988;R.B. Phillips, ‘Why not tourist art? Significant silences in Native American museum representations’, inG. Prakash(ed.), After Colonialism: Imperial Histories and Postcolonial Displacements,Princeton University Press,, 1995, pp.98-125;R.B. Phillips andC.B. Steiner, ‘Art, authenticity and the baggage of cultural encounter’, inR.B. Phillips andC.B. Steiner(eds), Unpacking Culture: Art and Commodity in Colonial and Postcolonial Worlds,University of California Press,, 1999, pp.3-19. Google Scholar

22.SeeJ. Fondas, Sailors Valentines,Rizzoli,, 2002. Google Scholar

23.For a description of the practice at Wallaga Lake on the far south coast, seeNash, ‘From shell work to shell art’. Google Scholar

24.NSW Legislative Council, ‘Report of the Protector of Aborigines, to 31 December 1882’, Senior-Constable Byrne to Protector of Aborigines, Journal of the NSW Legislative Council, vol.34, pt 2, p.315. Google Scholar

25.Aborigines Protection Board, Annual Report, inNSW Legislative Assembly Votes and Proceedings, 1892, cited inMcKenzie andStephen, ‘La Perouse’, p.179. See also‘The Blacks at La Perouse’, Letter to the Editor, Sydney Morning Herald, 14July1891, p.6. Google Scholar

26.SeeE.J. Telfer, Amongst Australian Aborigines: Forty Years of Missionary Work: The Story of the United Aborigines Mission,E.J. Telfer,, 1939. Google Scholar

27. The New South Wales Aborigines Advocate, 30June1903, pp.2-3. Google Scholar

28.‘The Aborigines at La Perouse’, Sydney Morning Herald, 13November1902, p.8. Google Scholar

29.Barwick, ‘And the ladies are lubras now’. Google Scholar

30.For a discussion of a comparable situation in which women’s participation in an informal economy contributed significantly to men’s earnings on the Sydney waterfront in the opening decades of the twentieth century, seeM. Beasley,Sarah Dawes andthe Coal Lumpers: Absence and Presence on the Sydney Waterfront, 1900-1917, PhD thesis,University of Wollongong, 2004, pp.86-89. Google Scholar

31.H. Goodall andA. Cadzow, Rivers and Resilience, pp.120-21. Google Scholar

32. The New South Wales Aborigines Advocate, 30September1903;30June1905;30November1908. Google Scholar

33.Phillips, Trading Identities, p.210. Google Scholar

34. The New South Wales Aborigines Advocate, 30June1903, p.3. Google Scholar

35.N. Stanley, ‘Melanesian artifacts as cultural markers: A micro-anthropological study’, inS.H. Riggins, The Socialness of Things: Essays on the Socio-Semiotics of Objects,Mouton de Gruyter,, 1994, p.173-99. Google Scholar

36. The Australian Aborigines Advocate, 30November1908, p.4. Google Scholar

37.‘Our Girls: What to do with them: Town Hall exhibition: Opened by Lady Dudley’, Sydney Morning Herald, 27April1911, p.7;The Australian Aborigines Advocate, 28February1910. Google Scholar

38.‘Miscellaneous exhibits: The Aborigines’, Australian Star, April1910. Google Scholar

39. Australian Aborigines Advocate, 31March1910. Google Scholar

41. Australian Aborigines Advocate, 31March1910;30April1910;29April1911. Google Scholar

42.J. Scott andR. Laurie, ‘Colonialism on display: Indigenous people and artefacts at an Australian agricultural show’, Aboriginal History, vol.31, 2007, pp.45-62. Google Scholar

43.See, for instance,Nugent, Botany Bay;Randwick Municipal Council, Randwick: A Social History,New South Wales University Press and Randwick Municipal Council,, 1985;P. Curby, Randwick,Randwick City Council,, 2009. Google Scholar

44.Phillips andSteiner, ‘Art, authenticity and the baggage of cultural encounter’. Google Scholar

45.J. Jago, ‘La Perouse’, United Aborigines Advocate, 1June1929. Google Scholar

47.S. Stewart, On Longing: Narratives of the Miniature, the Gigantic, the Souvenir, the Collection,John Hopkins University Press,, 1984. Google Scholar

48. United Aborigines Advocate, 30April1923. Google Scholar

50.SeeJ.H. Bell, The La Perouse Aborigines: A Study of their Group Life and Assimilation into Modern Australian Society, PhD thesis,University of Sydney, 1967, pp.273-79; Longbottom and Ryan, transcript of oral history interview;B. Beller, ‘Shellwork’. Google Scholar

52.Kleinert, Jacky Jacky, p.114, 122. Google Scholar

53.SeeBell, The La Perouse Aborigines, pp.273-79. Google Scholar

54.It is also possible that some Aboriginal men and boys were involved in making shellwork at different times. In some early references to its production, the gender of the makers is not always clear. See‘The Aborigines at La Perouse’, Sydney Morning Herald, 13November1902, p.8. Moreover, there are references to shellwork in England made by men and boys. See for instance:‘The Seaside Holiday’, The Child’s Companion, September1881, issue153, p.138, accessed online in19thCentury UK Periodicals,Galegroup, 29June2011. Google Scholar

55.SeeS. Kleinert, ‘Aboriginal enterprises: Negotiating an urban Aboriginal identity’, Aboriginal History, vol.34, 2010, pp.171-93;S. Kleinert, ‘Bill Onus’, DAAO,http://www.daao.org.au/main/read/7530, accessed 17 March 2011;J. Jones, Country Women and the Colour Bar(forthcoming);D. Byrne andM. Nugent, Mapping Attachment: A Spatial Approach to Aboriginal Post-Contact Heritage,Department of Environment (NSW),, 2004, pp.117-19. For an international comparison, see:F. Ettawageshik, ‘My father’s business’, inPhillips andSteiner(eds), Unpacking Culture, pp.20-29. Google Scholar

56. The Argus, 21June1944, p.14. Google Scholar

57.Gloria Ardler, ‘My grandmother and her family’, inIndividual Heritage Group, La Perouse. Google Scholar

59.SeeM. Nugent, ‘An economy of shells: A brief history of La Perouse Aboriginal women’s shellwork and its markets 1880-2010’, inI. Keen, M. Pickering,C. Lloyd andN. Fijn(eds), Indigenous Participation in Australian Economies, Volume 2,ANU E Press(forthcoming). Google Scholar

60.L. Ryan, ‘Shellwork: From Bridges to Maps’, inSteppin’ Out and Speakin’ Up,Older Women’s Network NSW,, 2003, pp.11-21. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Nugent, Maria