Labour History

Nuclear Migrants, Radical Protest, and the Transnational Movement against French Nuclear Testing in the 1960s: The 1967 Voyage of theTrident

Labour History (2016), 111, (1), 79–98.

Abstract

This article explores the origins and early years of the Australian movement against the French nuclear testing program in the South Pacific, which ran from 1966 to 1996. In particular, it looks at the transnational frame of Australian activism by focusing on an early example of direct action, the Committee Against Atomic Testing (CAAT). Established in Sydney in 1964, CAAT was conceived as a vehicle for organising the Trident protest voyage that sailed from Sydney towards French Polynesia in 1967. Although the voyage only travelled as far as the Cook Islands, it is significant for a number of reasons. Firstly, it illuminates the role of British and American migrants in radicalising the Sydney Left in the early to mid-1960s. Many of these, especially those from the United States, were self-described “nuclear migrants,” fleeing radioactive fallout, Cold War propaganda, and the excesses of materialism back home. Several were involved in CAAT, helping to radicalise its ideas and its place in broader, international trends of direct action and radical pacifism. Secondly, the campaign of the Trident and its evolution is illustrative of a broader trend of experimentation with radical protest in opposition to French nuclear testing that was garnering interest among many on the Left in Australia in the mid to late 1960s.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

Footnotes

1.On this opposition, which extended until the mid-1990s, seeLorraine Elliott, “French Nuclear Testing in the Pacific: A Retrospective,” Environmental Politics 6, no. 2(1997):144–49. Google Scholar

2.Sigrid McCausland, “Leave It in the Ground: The Anti-Uranium Movement in Australia, 1975–82”(PhD diss.,University of Technology,, 1999), 88–90. Google Scholar

3.On these voyages, seeLawrence Wittner, “The Long Voyage: The Golden Rule and Resistance to Nuclear Testing in Asia and the Pacific,” Asia-Pacific Journal 8, no. 3(2010). Two participant histories have also been influential:Albert Bigelow, The Voyage of the Golden Rule: An Experiment with Truth(:Doubleday, 1959); andEarle Reynolds, The Forbidden Voyage(:David McKay, 1961). Google Scholar

4.SeeScott Bennett, Radical Pacifism: The War Resisters League and Gandhian Nonviolence in America, 1915–1963(:Syracuse University Press, 2003);Joseph Kip Kosek, Acts of Conscience: Christian Nonviolence and Modern American Democracy(:Columbia University Press, 2009); andSean Scalmer, Gandhi in the West: The Mahatma and the Rise of Radical Protest(:Cambridge University Press, 2011). Google Scholar

5.Frank Zelko, Make It a Green Peace! The Rise of Countercultural Environmentalism(:Oxford University Press, 2013), 145. Google Scholar

6.Participant histories have been influential in this regard. Key examples includeDavid McTaggart, Outrage! The Ordeal of Greenpeace III(:J. J. Douglas, 1973);Michael Szabo, Making Waves(:Reed Books, 1991); andRex Weyler, Greenpeace: How a Group of Journalists, Ecologists and Visionaries Changed the World(:Rodale, 2004). Google Scholar

7.Key examples includeKevin Clements, Back from the Brink: The Creation of a Nuclear-Free New Zealand(:Allen & Unwin, 1988);David Lange, Nuclear Free: The New Zealand Way(:Penguin, 1990);Maire Leadbeater, Peace, Power & Politics: How New Zealand Became Nuclear Free(:Otago University Press, 2013);Rebecca Priestley, Mad on Radium: New Zealand in the Atomic Age(:Auckland University Press, 2012); andMalcolm Templeton, Standing Upright Here: New Zealand in the Nuclear Age 1945–1990(:Victoria University Press, 2006). Google Scholar

8.Malcolm Saunders andRalph Summy, “One Hundred Years of an Australian Peace Movement, 1885–1984,”parts 1 and 2, Peace & Change 10, no. 3–4(1984):39–75;Verity Burgmann, Power and Protest: Movements for Change in Australian Society(:Allen & Unwin, 1992); and, more recently, the essays inPhillip Deery andJulie Kimber, eds., Fighting Against War: Peace Activism in the Twentieth Century(:Leftbank Press, 2015). Google Scholar

9.SeeScalmer, Gandhi in the West. Google Scholar

10.See, for example,Ravi De Costa, A Higher Authority: Indigenous Transnationalism and Australia(:UNSW Press, 2006);Nick Irving, “Answering the ‘International Call’: Contextualising Sydney Anti-Nuclear and Anti-War Activism in the 1960s,” Journal of Australian Studies 40, no. 3(2016):291–301;Jon Piccini, Transnational Protest, Australia and the 1960s: Global Radicals(:Palgrave Macmillan, 2016); andSean Scalmer, Dissent Events: Protest, the Media, and the Political Gimmick in Australia(:UNSW Press, 2002). Google Scholar

11.Kate Murphy, “‘In the Backblocks of Capitalism’: Australian Student Activism in the Global 1960s,” Australian Historical Studies 46, no. 2(2015):252–68;Piccini, Transnational Protest, ch. 4. Google Scholar

12.Stephen Alomes, “Cultural Radicalism in the Sixties,” Arena 62(1983), 31. Google Scholar

13.A. James Hammerton andAlistair Thomson, Ten Pound Poms: Australia’s Invisible Migrants(:Manchester University Press, 2005), 32;David Mosler andBob Catley, America and Americans in Australia(:Praeger, 1998), 75–76. Google Scholar

14.Limited scholarship has been conducted on this issue. For a brief discussion, seeJon Piccini, “‘Australia’s Most Evil and Repugnant Nightspot’: Foco Club and Transnational Politics in Brisbane’s ‘68,” Dialogue e-Journal 8, no. 1(2010), 3–6. Google Scholar

15.“New Moves to Halt H-Tests,” Peace News, 1 March1957, 1, 6. Google Scholar

16.This movement has been dealt with extensively by historians. SeeRobert Divine, Blowing on the Wind: The Nuclear Test Ban Debate, 1954–1960(:Oxford University Press, 1978); andLawrence Wittner, Resisting the Bomb: A History of the World Nuclear Disarmament Movement, 1954–1970(:Stanford University Press, 1997). Google Scholar

17.Sylvia Martin, Ink in Her Veins: The Troubled Life of Aileen Palmer(:UWA Publishing, 2016), 247–48;Ric Throssell, Wild Weeds and Windflowers: The Life and Letters of Katharine Susannah Prichard(:Allen & Unwin, 2012), 198–99. Google Scholar

18.It is unclear whether any vessels sailed from Japan – with an entirely Japanese crew – or not.Peace Newsreported plans for a fleet of nine vessels (“H-Test News in Brief,” 12 April1957, 6), and later, two vessels (“Harold Steele,”31 May1957, 10). These reports were not followed up. Google Scholar

19.ASIO memo, 27 May1957, A6119, 2174, National Archives of Australia (hereafter NAA). Google Scholar

20.Katharine Susannah Prichard toWilliam Morrow, 4 May1957, MLMSS 5522, Box 73, Folder“Correspondence 1957,”People for Nuclear Disarmament Records (hereafter PND Records),Mitchell Library,;Martin, Ink in Her Veins, 248. Google Scholar

21.Lange, Nuclear Free, 11. See also reports from across the South Pacific in“Beep! And the Pacific Became Weird,” Pacific Islands Monthly 33, no. 1(August1962), 15–16. Google Scholar

22.Templeton, Standing Upright Here, 99. Google Scholar

23. Ibid., 122. Google Scholar

24.See“National Petition Launched,”and“Nuclear Free Zone in Southern Hemisphere Urged by Calwell,” Peace Action, June1962, 2, 8. Google Scholar

25.“Ban the Bomb Marchers in Canberra,” Peace Action, September1962, 3. Google Scholar

26.Elsie Locke, Peace People: A History of Peace Activities in New Zealand(:Hazard Press, 1992), 180. Google Scholar

27.Templeton, Standing Upright Here, 124. Google Scholar

28.Szabo, Making Waves, 13. Google Scholar

29.F. W. Bowen, Report of ACTU Fraternal Delegate to NZFL 26th Annual Conference, [May1963], Australian Council of Trade Unions Deposit 1, N21 (hereafter N21), item 1482, Noel Butlin Archives Centre, Australian National University (hereafter NBAC). Google Scholar

30.“Australian and Indonesian Wharfies Warn on French Tests,” Tribune, 30 October1963, 12; and“Call for Joint Action to Stop French Tests,” Tribune, 6 November1963, 8. Google Scholar

31.J. C. Chandler, “NZ Union Conference Made History,” Building Worker, January/February1964, 5. Google Scholar

32.Jack Beitz toAlbert Monk, 16 March1964, Australian Railways Union National Office Deposit 1, N5 (hereafter N5), item 778, NBAC. Google Scholar

33.Albert Monk toKenneth Baxter, 31 July1964, N21, item 1483. Google Scholar

34.On this history, seeFrank Farrell, “The Pan-Pacific Trade Union Movement and Australian Labour, 1921–1932,” Historical Studies 17, no. 69(1977):441–57. On a similar post-war proposal, see“TU Conference for Pacific Supported,” Tribune, 4 August1948, 7. Google Scholar

35.Albert Monk toKenneth Baxter, 28 July1965, N21, item 1483. Google Scholar

36.Albert Monk, circular, 22 October1965;Thomas Skinner toAlbert Monk, 28 October1965, both in N21, item 1483. Google Scholar

37.Albert Monk andThomas Skinner, conference circular, 22 October1965, N21, item 1483. Google Scholar

38.Conference declaration, [December1965], Australian Council of Trade Unions Deposit 2, N68 (hereafter N68), item 508, NBAC. Google Scholar

39.Frank Purse toAlbert Monk, 21 December1965, N68, item 508. Google Scholar

40.Robert Stowell, memorandum to New Zealand CND National Committee, March1964, Papers relating to New Zealand folk music and nuclear disarmament, MS-Papers-11739-4, Alexander Turnbull Library, Wellington, New Zealand. Google Scholar

41.Other avenues of protest suggested were a shipping embargo, a New Zealand-sponsored resolution opposing the tests at the United Nations, and a “special conference of Southern Hemisphere Pacific Nations.” See“CRAFT Against De Gaulle: Auckland Students Plan Sitting in at French Bomb Test!” Salient(Victoria University student newspaper), 21 September1964, 1. Google Scholar

42.Quoted inSandra Irving, “French Tests,” Outlook 8, no. 6(December1964), 10. Google Scholar

44.Quoted inIrving, “French Tests,” 10. Google Scholar

45.Juliet Richter, email to the author, 22 August2016. Google Scholar

46.Janice Symons toAva Helen Pauling, 23 January1963and 27 July1964, Section 15, Box 1.006.17, Ava Helen and Linus Pauling Papers (hereafter Pauling Papers), Oregon State University Libraries, Corvallis. Google Scholar

47.The literature here is vast, but for some pertinent examples, seeVera Mackie, “From Hiroshima to Lausanne: The World Congress of Mothers and the Hahaoya Taikai in the 1950s,” Women’s History Review 25, no. 4(2016):671–95;Amy Swerdlow, Women Strike for Peace: Traditional Motherhood and Radical Politics in the 1960s(:University of Chicago Press, 1993); andLawrence Wittner, “Gender Roles and Nuclear Disarmament Activism, 1954–1965,” Gender & History 12, no. 1(2000):197–222. Google Scholar

48.“She Plans to Sail Into Test Bomb Site,” Age, 20 November1964, 11. Google Scholar

49.“Women to Sail Protest Ship to A-Test Area,” North Shore Times, 25 November1964, 1. Google Scholar

50.ASIO memo, 5 January1965, A6126, 1391, NAA. Google Scholar

51.“Father Risks His Life for Nuclear Test Ban,” Advance, 14 October1965, 1. Google Scholar

52.“Woman with a Job,” Australian, 19 November1964, 1; ASIO memo, 22 May1963, A6126, 1392, NAA. Google Scholar

53.Ralph Summy, “Militancy and the Australian Peace Movement, 1960–67,” Politics 5, no. 2(1970), 152. Google Scholar

54.Irving, “Answering the International Call.” Google Scholar

55.Janice Symons to Ava Helen Pauling, 14 June 1962, Section 15, Box 1.006.17, Pauling Papers;“Bertrand Russell Peace Foundation,” Outlook 8, no. 4(August1964), 24; French-Australian Goodwill Tour, National Committee of Sponsors list, [1964], Seamen’s Union of Australia, Sydney Branch Deposit, Z91 (hereafter Z91), box 29, NBAC. Google Scholar

56.SeeScalmer, Dissent Events, 51–55. Google Scholar

57.“Voila!” Daily Telegraph, 5 January1965, 1;“Launch Challenges Big Ships,” Tribune, 13 January1965, 1. Google Scholar

58.“Call to ACTU,” Tribune, 3 February1965, 9. Google Scholar

59.CAAT pamphlet, “French Planning H-Tests for 196?,”pamphlet file Q355.232/2,Mitchell Library,. Google Scholar

60.Edward Stanton, CAAT circular, 26 April 1966, Z91, box 30. Google Scholar

61.Robert Smith to chairman and delegates of South Pacific Trade Union Conference, 6 December1965, N68, item 508; CAAT media release, 18 July1966, pamphlet file Q355.232/2, Mitchell Library, Sydney. Google Scholar

62.NSW Police to Deputy Director General, “D” Branch, 22 April1966, A6126, 1392, NAA;“For Your Sake!”CAAT flyer, [April1966], A6119, 6437, NAA. Google Scholar

63.ASIO report, 19 April1966, A6119, 6437, NAA. Google Scholar

64.Gilmore was at one time a member of the Youth Campaign Against Conscription, and was arrested with many others at a violent Vietnam Action Committee demonstration in October 1965. SeeVietnam Action Committee evaluation, 22 October1965, A6126, 1391, NAA. Google Scholar

65.Advertisement, Humanist, 1 July1962, 134;Lloyd Wilkie toLinus Pauling, 13 April1963and 9 February1964, Section 12, Box 8.006.36, Pauling Papers. Google Scholar

66.Janice Symons, letter to the editor, Outlook 8, no. 2(April1964), 16;Lloyd Wilkie, letter to the editor, Australian, 28 April1965, copy in A6119, 6495, NAA. Wilkie signed the letter as a member of the“American Nuclear Migrants Society.” Google Scholar

68.“Appointments on Probation,” Government Gazette of NSW, 29 July1966, 3051. Google Scholar

69.American migrants were far fewer in number than British migrants in these years, yet Americans seem to have emigrated more frequently for political and ideological concerns, rather than economic reasons. However, “white flight” from American cities then suffering from social decay and racial violence may also have been a factor for many migrants. SeeMosler andCatley, America and Americans, 91–92. Google Scholar

70.Patricia Rolfe, “Australia’s Nuclear Migrants: Mostly from America,” Bulletin, 16 November1963, 24. Google Scholar

71.Helen Palmer, “The Fractured Dream,”editorial, Outlook 7, no. 5(October1963), 5–6. Google Scholar

72.Norman Cousins, “Return of the Native,”editorial, Saturday Review, 4 July1964, 14. Google Scholar

73.J. Anthony Lukas, “U.S. Migrants Regard New Zealand as Nuclear-War Haven,” New York Times, 28 January1964, 4. Google Scholar

74.P. Anna Johnson, Australia Years: The Life of a Nuclear Migrant(:Lulu Press, 2006), 6–7. Google Scholar

75. Ibid., 28. Google Scholar

76.Irene Summy, “Price of Protection,” Outlook 7, no. 5(October1963), 7. Google Scholar

77.Mosler andCatley, America and Americans, 91–92. Google Scholar

78.Johnson, Australia Years, 39. Google Scholar

79.Cletus Oakley obituary, New York Times, 16 November1990, B8. Google Scholar

80.Rilka Oakley, informal conversation with the author, 4 July2016, Sydney;Scott Merriman, Religion and the Law in America: An Encyclopedia of Personal Belief and Public Policy(:ABCCLIO, 2007), 77–78. Google Scholar

81.Marian Mollin, Radical Pacifism in Modern America: Egalitarianism and Protest(:University of Pennsylvania Press, 2006), 90. Google Scholar

82.On the CNVA, its history, and its splintering due to different approaches to radical action, seeMaurice Isserman, “The Irony of American Pacifism,” Peace & Change 11, no. 3–4(1986):47–66. Google Scholar

83.Zelko, Make It a Green Peace, 20. Google Scholar

84.Robert Stowell, Toward Simple Living(:Solitarian Press, 1955). Google Scholar

85.Ann Stowell, informal telephone conversation with the author, 19 August2016;Nancy Zaroulis andGerald Sullivan, Who Spoke Up? American Protest Against the War in Vietnam, 1963–1975(:Doubleday, 1984), 57. Google Scholar

86.Weyler, Greenpeace, 40–41. Google Scholar

87.Robert Stowell, “Intentional Community,”letter to the editor, Catholic Worker, March1962, 4. Google Scholar

88.Review ofWorld War III and the Southern HemispherebyLawrence Ross, a Canadian “nuclear migrant” living in Christchurch, inNew Zealand Christian Pacifist 17, no. 10(November1963):8. Google Scholar

90.Peter Mudie, Ubu Films: Sydney Underground Movies, 1965–1970(:UNSW Press, 1997), 27, 110; Rilka Oakley conversation. Google Scholar

91.“C.A.A.T.,” Peacemaker, March–April1966, 3; CAAT media release, 18 July1966. Google Scholar

92.“Protest Cruise Against Nuclear Test,” Pacific Islands Monthly 37, no. 2(February1966), 101. Google Scholar

93.John Gilpin toEdward Stanton, 4 May1966, Gladney Oakley Papers (hereafter Oakley Papers), MLMSS 4809, Mitchell Library, Sydney; John Gilpin, email to the author, 3 September2016. Google Scholar

94.Gladney Oakley, letter to supporters, 12 August1966, John Fallding Papers, MLMSS 7251, Mitchell Library, Sydney;“The Good Ship ‘Humanity’ Cried Wolf,” Sydney Morning Herald, 11 August1966, 6. Google Scholar

95.Lincoln Anderson, “The Dark Side of Purple,” The Villager, 31 December2015, accessed October2016,http://thevillager.com/2015/12/31/the-dark-side-of-purple;Lincoln Anderson, “All Purple’s Daughters,” The Villager, 21 January2016, accessed October 2016,http://thevillager.com/2016/01/21/all-purples-daughters. Google Scholar

96.Bill of Sale 316404, Transactions 1 and 2, 15 June1966and 18 November1966, Oakley Papers. Google Scholar

97.ASIO initial evaluation, August1962, A6119, 6440, NAA. Google Scholar

99.See, for example, attendance list for WWF social, 10 July1965; and attendance list, EYL debate on Vietnam, 17 September1965, both in A6119, 6440, NAA. Google Scholar

100.Darcy Wilms, interview with the author, 21 May2014, Sydney; Brian Aarons, informal conversation with the author, 25 July2016, Sydney. Google Scholar

101.ASIO described it as “something of a flat campaign.”J. W. Clowes, CAAT evaluation, 19 April1966, A6119, 6437, NAA. Google Scholar

102.“Last Sunday Afternoon,” Tharunka, 30 March1967, 16. Google Scholar

103.Brian Haas toBob Smith, [April1967], Oakley Papers. Google Scholar

104.Richard Northey, email to the author, 18 February2016. Google Scholar

105.“French Bomb Protest Yacht Arrives,” Cook Islands News, 6 June1967, 6. Google Scholar

106.Albert Henry toBob Smith, 7 June1967, Oakley Papers. Google Scholar

107.Brian Haas toGeoff Anderson, 6 June1967, Box 65, Folder “CAAT,” PND Records. Google Scholar

108. CAAT Newsletter, no. 5, 21 August1967, 5. Google Scholar

109.CAAT Final Report, 1 October1968, A6119, 6447, NAA. Google Scholar

110.Darcy Wilms interview. Google Scholar

111.Rilka Oakley conversation. Google Scholar

112.ASIO memo, 17 October1967, A6119, 6441, NAA. Google Scholar

113.“No Protest Voyage for the French Bomb,” Sydney Morning Herald, 10 July1968, 6. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Harvey, Kyle