Labour History

Pursuing Trade Union Internationalism: Australia’s Waterside Workers and the International Transport Workers Federation, c. 1950–70

Labour History (2016), 110, (1), 57–75.

Abstract

When the Australian Waterside Workers Federation (WWF) decided in 1971 to join the International Transport Workers Federation (ITF) it overturned decades of antipathy to the ITF. We ask why union officials held this view and why the union now changed its mind at this particular moment. We argue that while union power was strong in the immediate postwar decades, the WWF was able to pursue its economic goals locally and join international actions for reasons of solidarity. In the following decade, however, union archives reveal that a confluence of technological change and diminishing union strength under a conservative government made international organising a logical and necessary strategy. Under the guidance of General Secretary Charlie Fitzgibbon, the WWF overcame its opposition to the ITF, by then an organisation representing millions of workers worldwide. We concentrate on Fitzgibbon’s leadership as a crucial factor in the timing of this historic change.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*Research for this article was funded by an Australian Research Council Linkage Project with the Maritime Union of Australia. We wish to thank the ARC, the MUA and theLabour History’sthree anonymous referees for their help. Google Scholar

1.“Overseas Study to Aid Negotiations,” Maritime Worker, 27 May1971, 1. Google Scholar

2.See correspondence in ITF archives, Modern Records Centre, University of Warwick;Tom Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War: The Waterfront Under Menzies(:Melbourne University Press, 2006), 124–25;Margo Beasley, Wharfies: The History of the Waterside Workers’ Federation(:Halstead Press in association with Australian National Maritime Museum, 1996)64–65, 150–53, 214. Google Scholar

3.ITF, Solidarity: The First 100 Years of the International Transport Workers’ Federation(:Pluto Press, 1996). Google Scholar

4.H. Lewis, “The International Transport Workers’ Federation (ITF) 1945–1965: An Organizational and Political Anatomy”(PhD thesis,Warwick University, 2003), 365, table 6. Google Scholar

5. Ibid., 178. Google Scholar

6.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War;, Wharfies;Wendy Lowenstein andT. Hills, Under the Hook: Melbourne Waterside Workers Remember Working Lives and Class War: 1900–1980(:Melbourne Bookworkers, 1982);Rupert Lockwood, Ship to Shore: A History of Melbourne’s Waterfront and its Union Struggles(:Hale & Iremonger, 1990);Greg Mallory, Uncharted Waters: Social Responsibility in Australian Trade Unions(:Boolarong Press, 2005);J. S. Ahlquist andM. Levi, In the Interest of Others: Organizations and Social Activism(:Princeton University Press, 2013). Google Scholar

7.Beasley, Wharfies, 216–20, 235;Lowenstein andHills, Under the Hook, 168. Google Scholar

8.Beasley, Wharfies. Google Scholar

9.S. Le Queux, “Australian Trade Union Politics in International Perspective: Which Way Forward?” Labour & Industry 21, no. 3(2011):555–71;A. Forsyth, “Worker Representation in Australia: Moving Towards Overseas Models?” Australian Bulletin of Labour 33, no. 1(2007):1–31. Google Scholar

10.ITF, 25th Congress, Amsterdam, 23 July to 1 August 1958, Report on Activities for the Years 1956 and 1957(:ITF), 29;ITF, Reports 1958–1959 and Proceedings of 26th Congress, Berne 26–30 July 1960(:ITF), 18–19;ITF, 75th Anniversary and 30th Congress, Vienna 28th July to 6th August 1971, Report on Activities for the years 1968, 1969 and 1970(:ITF), 23. Google Scholar

11.ITF, Report on Activities and Financial Report of the ITF for the years 1938 to 1946 and Proceedings …(:ITF, 1946), 14;ITF, Reports 1958–1959, 17. Google Scholar

12.Tasnor Bull, Life on the Waterfront: An Autobiography(:HarperCollins, 1998), 131. Google Scholar

13.D. Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change on Industrial Relations in the Australian Stevedoring Industry 1950–1972”(PhD thesis,University of New South Wales, 1976), 90;R. Lockwood, Ship to Shore: A History of Melbourne’s Waterfront and Its Union Struggles(:Hale & Iremonger, 1990). Google Scholar

14.R. Markey andS. Svensen, “Healy, James (Jim) (1898–1961)”inAustralian Dictionary of Biography, volume 14(National Centre of Biography, Australian National University1996);Charlie Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, typescript, Charles Fitzgibbon Papers, P 102/91, 48, Noel Butlin Archives of Business and Labour, Canberra (hereafter NBAC);Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 93. Google Scholar

15.Beasley, Wharfies, 140–41;Robin Gollan, Revolutionaries and Reformists: Communism and the Australian Labour Movement, 1920–1955(:George Allen & Unwin, 1985), 282;Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 70. Google Scholar

16.“General Sec. Writes from Moscow,” Maritime Worker, 16 December1950, 1;“Unanimous Report by Delegation to Soviet Union,” Maritime Worker, 14 March1953, 5;“Report on China by Roach, Young,” Maritime Worker, 18 May1953, 6;“Soviet Wharfies Now Reaping Fruits of Working Power,” Maritime Worker, 9 November1954, 6;“New China’s Freedom and Speedy Progress Impress Delegate,” Maritime Worker, 9 August1955, 5;“Moran at May Day in Soviet Union,” Maritime Worker, 24 May1955, 7, and others. Google Scholar

17.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 69–70. Google Scholar

18.“Menzies: Fascist without Shirt!” Maritime Worker, 24 August1946, 4;“Little Dictator,” Maritime Worker, 24 June1950, 1. Google Scholar

19.International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, Twenty Years ICFTU 1949–1969(:ICFTU, 1969), 8. Google Scholar

20.A. Carew, “The World Federation of Trade Unions 1945–1949,”inThe International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, ed.Marcel van der Linden(:P. Lang, 2000), 172–73;R. F. Staar, Foreign Policies of the Soviet Union(:Hoover Institution Press, Stanford University, 1991), 79. Google Scholar

21.A. Carew, “Towards a Free Trade Union Centre: The International Confederation of Free Trade Unions”invan der Linden, International Confederation of Free Trade Unions, 195–98. Google Scholar

22.“International Protest on the Prosecution of Harry Bridges,” Maritime Worker, 24 December1949, 3. Google Scholar

23.V. Williams, The Years of Big Jim(:Lone Hand Press1975), 122. Google Scholar

24.“WFTU Call for Unity of World Unions,” Maritime Worker, 25 August1951, 8;“Wharfies Need the W.F.T.U,” Maritime Worker, 19 April1952, 6;“WFTU Unity to End Poverty, War,” Maritime Worker, 14 July1953, 6;“WFTO Warns of War Plans,” Maritime Worker, 7 June1955, 8;“Unions Condemn Raids on WFTU,” Maritime Worker, 20 March1956, 7;“Australians Attend WFTU,” Maritime Worker, 5 November1957, 1and others. Google Scholar

25.ITF, Solidarity, 111. Google Scholar

26.Lewis, “International Transport Workers’ Federation,” 178–79. Google Scholar

27.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 60;Williams, Years of Big Jim, 59, 69. Google Scholar

28. Stevedoring Industry Act of 1947, item 27. Google Scholar

29.Beasley, Wharfies, 118. Google Scholar

30.C. Fitzgibbon, “The March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 15 March1967, 2–3. Google Scholar

31.Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 109. Google Scholar

32.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 92;A. Bach, A Maritime History of Australia(:Thomas Nelson Australia, 1976), 376–77. Google Scholar

33.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 69. Google Scholar

34. Report of the Australian Stevedoring Industry Board(1950):16. Google Scholar

35.Robert Menzies, The Measure of the Years(:Coronet Books, 1972), 131. Google Scholar

36.“Man to Man: Australia Today,” a series of speeches byR. G. Menzies, 18 March 1953, cited inC. Hazlehurst, Menzies Observed(:George Allen & Unwin Australia, 1979), 334–35. Google Scholar

37.Beasley, Wharfies, 168;Williams, Years of Big Jim, 133–41. Google Scholar

38.Williams, Years of Big Jim, 140. Google Scholar

39. Ibid., 139;Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 102. Google Scholar

40.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 228;Williams, Years of Big Jim, 158–59;Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 89. Google Scholar

41.Jim Beggs, Proud to be a Wharfie(:Arcadia, 2013), 112. Google Scholar

42. Ibid. Google Scholar

43.W. J. Brown, The Communist Movement and Australia(:Australian Labor Movement History Publications, 1986), 183. Google Scholar

44.Alistair Davidson, The Communist Party of Australia: A Short History(:Hoover Institution, 1969), 93. Google Scholar

45. Ibid., 142. Google Scholar

46.T. O’Lincoln, Into the Mainstream: The Decline of Australian Communism(:Red Rag, 2009), 117–24;Davidson, Communist Party, 149. Google Scholar

47.Davidson, Communist Party, 157. Google Scholar

48.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 65. Google Scholar

49. Ibid., 65. Google Scholar

50.Beggs, Proud to be a Wharfie, 112, 118–19. Google Scholar

51.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 21–22. Google Scholar

52. Labor Year Book(:Mass Communications Australia, 1973), 244;R. M. Martin, “The ACTU Congress of 1983,” Labour History, no. 45(November1983):101. Google Scholar

53.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 39. Google Scholar

54. Ibid., 48;D. Stephens, “Unity Tickets and the Victorian Branch of the ALP,” Labour History, no. 44(May1983):70–71. Google Scholar

55.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 48. Google Scholar

56.Blanche d’Alpuget, Robert J. Hawke: A Biography(:Schwartz and Lansdowne Press, 1982), 230–31. Google Scholar

57.R. J. Hawke, The Hawke Memoirs(:William Heinemann Australia, 1994), 52. Google Scholar

58.Beggs, Proud to be a Wharfie, 118–19. Google Scholar

59.Fitzgibbon, “March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 15 March1967, 2;E. Bonacoch andB. Wilson, Getting the Goods: Ports, Labor and the Logistic Revolution(:Cornell University Press, 2007), 50, 172;B. J. Cudahy, Box Boats: How Container Ships Changed the World(:Fordham University Press, 2006), 8–10;M. Levinson, The Box: How the Shipping Container Made the World Smaller and the World Economy Bigger(:Princeton University Press, 2006), chapter 2, 16–35. Google Scholar

60.Australian Stevedoring Industry Authority (hereafter ASIA), Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1961, 17;D. Hull, “Queensland Sugar Ports: Labour and Technological Change,” Journal of Australian Political Economy, no. 6(1979):60–72. Google Scholar

61.Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 127. Google Scholar

62.ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1958, 45;ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1963, 22–30. Google Scholar

63.ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1963, 22;Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 312–13. Google Scholar

64.ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1963, 22–23. Google Scholar

65.Fitzgibbon, “March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 15 March1967, 4. Google Scholar

66.“Union Talks on Containers,” Maritime Worker, 15 June1966, 1. Google Scholar

67.Charlie Fitzgibbon, Report on Containerisation and General Shipping Development, P 102/92,NBAC. Google Scholar

68.Fitzgibbon, “March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 15 March1967, 4;Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 256–63. Google Scholar

69.S. Deery, “The Impact of Technological Change on Union Structure: The Waterside Workers Federation,” Journal of Industrial Relations 25, no. 4(1983):401–402;Charlie Fitzgibbon, “Containerisation and Areas of Work,” Maritime Worker, 26 July1967, 5. Google Scholar

70.Beasley, Wharfies, 201, 213–14;ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1961, 40–42;ASIA, Report for the Year Ended 30th June 1962, 51, 59. Google Scholar

71.Calculated fromASIA, Annual Reports. Google Scholar

72.Jim Hagan, The History of the A.C.T. U.(:Longman Cheshire, 1981), 356;Labor Year Book(1973):213;“Approval for Wharf Stoppage,” CanberraTimes, 5 April1962, 13;“National Port Halt Approve,” Canberra Times, 14 May1963, 3;“Waterside Slate Ruling,” Canberra Times, 10 May1963, 3;“Watersiders to Ask ACTU Aid,” Canberra Times, 27 September1965, 3. Google Scholar

73.Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,” 226. Google Scholar

74.R. Cooksey, “Political Review,” Australian Quarterly 37, no. 4(December1965):100–101;J. Gaul, “Communist Weapon, Bitter Attack on Wharf Bill,” Canberra Times, 1 October1965, 1;J. Gaul, “Waterfront Bill: ALP Fights a Losing Battle,” Canberra Times, 7 October1965, 1. Google Scholar

75.Cited inS. Deery, “The Impact of the National Stevedoring Industry Conference (1965–67) on Industrial Relations on the Australian Waterfront,” Journal of Industrial Relations 20, no. 2(1978):208. Google Scholar

76. Minutes of WWF Federal Council Meeting, 19 October1962, N 114/131,NBAC. Google Scholar

79.ITF, Flags of Convenience: The ITF’s Campaign(:ITF, 1992), 20. “Flag of convenience” carriers are those registered in countries different to their owners. Google Scholar

80.ASIA, Report for Year Ended 30th June 1958, 43. Google Scholar

81.Fitzgibbon, “The March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 29 March1967, 8. Google Scholar

82.“Healy Exposes False Attacks on I.L.O Tour,” Maritime Worker, 26 February1957, 1. Google Scholar

83.Sheridan, Australia’s Own Cold War, 257. Google Scholar

84.“Parley for Wharfies,” Maritime Worker, 22 December1958, 5;“Second Pacific Dock Conference in 1960,” Maritime Worker, 2 June1959, 3;“Ted Roach Tells Big Part Played by Japan Dockers,” Maritime Worker, 30 August1961, 5; Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 40–42; WWF Correspondence with All Japan Dockers’ Union, 1961–62, N114/91, NBAC. Google Scholar

85.ITF, Solidarity, 113. Google Scholar

86.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 41–42. Google Scholar

87.Bonacoch andWilson, Getting the Goods, 178. Google Scholar

88.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 72. Google Scholar

89. Ibid., 73–75. Google Scholar

90.Charlie Fitzgibbon, C.V., P 102/26, NBAC;Bull, Life on the Waterfront, 105. Google Scholar

91.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 87–91, 110, 162; Industry Training Overseas Papers, Z432/39, NBAC; WWF Correspondence with Overseas Unions for 1968, N114/111, NBAC. Google Scholar

92.Hull, “The Impact of Major Technological Change,”chapter 4. Google Scholar

93.WWF Correspondence with Overseas Unions for 1965, the quote taken from Fitzgibbon’s letter to T. O’Leary, then Secretary of deckers section of British Transport and General Workers’ Union, N114/101, NBAC;“Overseas Study to Aid Negotiations,” Maritime Worker, 27 May1971, 1. Google Scholar

95.Fitzgibbon, Report on Containerisation, P 102/92, NBAC. Google Scholar

97.“Pacific Unions Talks on Container Age Mooted,” Maritime Worker, 18 August1969, 7;“Fitzgibbon on Overseas Tour,” Maritime Worker, 17 June1971, 1. Google Scholar

98.Fitzgibbon, “The March of Mechanisation,” Maritime Worker, 29 March1967, 8. Google Scholar

99.Charlie Fitzgibbon Interviewed byRichard Raxworthy in the Labor Council of New South Wales Oral History Project, 1986, typescript, ORAL TRC 1948/19, National Library of Australia; also P 102/21, NBAC. Google Scholar

101.Lewis, “International Transport Workers’ Federation,” 365, table 6. Google Scholar

102.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 175. Google Scholar

103. Ibid., 163. Google Scholar

104.Cooksey, “Political Review,” 100–101. Google Scholar

105. Ibid., 101. Google Scholar

108.Fitzgibbon, Autobiography, 163, 174. Google Scholar

109. Ibid., 163, 166. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Kirkby, Diane

Ostapenko, Dmytro