Labour History

Industry Superannuation Funds: A New Kind of Mutual

Labour History (2017), 112, (1), 25–43.

Abstract

At the time of the founding of the industry superannuation funds, the Australian retirement-savings market was dominated by insurance mutuals. In the early 1980s, less than half the workforce was covered by occupational superannuation and unions saw the insurance mutuals, created in the nineteenth century, as part of the problem in this widespread market failure. When establishing industry-wide schemes, union leaders largely eschewed the language associated with the “old” mutuals that had become key pillars of the established financial sector. In framing their appeal to members, the trustees and managers of the industry funds appealed instead to new expressions, such as “all profit to members.” Industry funds also developed a model of 50/50 employer/employee trusteeship or “equal representation” not as an ideological prescription, but as a pragmatic way of dealing with opposition to the schemes by employers. The trustees and managers of industry superannuation funds contrasted rather than associated themselves with the “old mutuals” which, at the time, were not seen as reflecting the unions’ ideal of an industrial partnership. However, with the decline and demutualisation of the largest old insurance mutuals in the 1990s, the industry funds began to appropriate the language of mutualism. This appropriation took place within the context of a perceived need to maintain a collective identity and purpose in the changing superannuation marketplace.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Footnotes

*The authors would like to thank Labour History’s two anonymous referees, the editors of this thematic, and the other participants of the associated workshop held at Macquarie University. Thanks are also due to Garry Weaven for his comments. This paper was produced as part of the “Workers’ Capital” project at RMIT, funded by the Australian Institute of Superannuation Trustees with the support of Industry Super Holdings. All interviews were conducted by the authors with some co-conducted by Cathy Brigden. Eleanor Bentham helped with some of the archival work. Google Scholar

1.Robert Owen, Report to the County of Lanark (Glasgow: University Press, 1821), 28–30; Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, Manuel du spéculateur à la bourse, 5th ed. (Paris: Garnier, 1857), 481–82. Google Scholar

2.Anthony Giddens, The Third Way and Its Critics (Cambridge: Polity, 2000); Johnston Birchall, The New Mutualism in Public Policy (London: Routledge, 2001). Google Scholar

3.Pierre-Joseph Proudhon, De la justice dans la révolution et dans l’église, vol. 1 (Paris: Garnier, 1858), 203. Google Scholar

5.Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA), “Celebrating 10 Years of Superannuation Data Collection 1996–2006,” APRA Insight 2 (2007): 18–20. Google Scholar

6.Rasmus K. Hartmann, “Subversive Functionalism: For a Less Canonical Critique in Critical Management Studies,” Human Relations 67, no. 5 (2014): 611–32; Michael Rowlinson, Andrea Casey, Per Hansen and Albert Mills, “Narratives and Memory in Organizations,” Organization 21, no. 4 (2014): 441–46. Google Scholar

7.Gwynneth Singleton, The Accord and the Australian Labour Movement (Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, 1990); Diana Shaw, “Trade Union Participation in Public Policy: The Rise and Demise of Australia’s National Retirement Income Regime” (PhD diss., University of NSW, 1992). Google Scholar

8.Monica Keneley, “Demutualisation in the Life Insurance Industry: A Preliminary Assessment,” Economic Papers 21, no. 2 (2002): 66–79; Monica Keneley, “The Demise of the Mutual Life Insurer: An Analysis of the Impact of Regulatory Change on the Performance of Australian Life Insurers in the 1990s,” Accounting History 15 (2010): 65–91. Google Scholar

9.Richard I. Downing, “Portability and Preservation of Benefits,” Superfunds, December 1970, 11–15; ACTU, “Superannuation,” circular no. 359, 19 October 1984, BUS Superannuation, N129/310, Noel Butlin Archive Centre (hereafter NBAC). Google Scholar

10.ACTU, “Superannuation”; Nikola Balnave, “Industrial Welfarism in Australia, 1890–1965” (PhD diss., University of Sydney, 2002). Google Scholar

11.Diana Olsberg, Ageing and Money: Australia’s Retirement Revolution (St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin, 1997); Mary Easson, “Present at the Creation: The Origins of the Australian System of Superannuation” (MPhil thesis, University of NSW, 2013), 75–96; Garry Weaven, “Workers’ Capital: The Story of Industry Funds and Australia’s Superannuation Revolution,” Foenander Lecture, Melbourne University, 16 November 2016. Google Scholar

12.ALP/ACTU, “Statement of Accord by the Australian Labor Party and the Australian Council of Trade Unions regarding Economic Policy,” February 1983; Singleton, The Accord and the Australian Labour Movement, 134–54. Google Scholar

13.Easson, “Present at the Creation,” 44. Google Scholar

14.William A. Landeryou, “The Union Attitude to Superannuation,” Superfunds, December 1978, 30–31; Simon Crean, “How One Union Won an Improved Super Scheme,” Australian Financial Review, 24 September 1979. Google Scholar

15.Keith Martin, “Prices-Income Deal to Be Reviewed,” Sydney Morning Herald, 21 January 1983, 22. Google Scholar

16.ALP/ACTU, “Agreement between the Government and the ACTU regarding Implementation of the Accord over the Next Two Years” (Accord Mark II), September 1985. Google Scholar

17.Anne-Marie Boxall and James Gillespie, Making Medicare: The Politics of Universal Health Care in Australia (Sydney: UNSW Press, 2013); Easson, “Present at the Creation,” 47–52. Google Scholar

18.Paul Kelly, The March of Patriots: The Struggle for Modern Australia (Carlton, Vic.: Melbourne University Press, 2009), 145. Google Scholar

19.Arthur C. Gray, Life Insurance in Australia: An Historical and Descriptive Account (Melbourne: McCarron Bird, 1977); David D. Green and Lawrence G. Cromwell, Mutual Aid or Welfare State: Australia’s Friendly Societies (Sydney: Allen & Unwin, 1984). Google Scholar

20.National Mutual Life Association of Australasia, A Century of Life: The Story of the First One Hundred Years of the National Mutual Life (Melbourne: NMLA, 1969), 125–26; Peter C. Wickens, The City Mutual Story: A Century of Service to Australians 1878–1978 (Sydney: City Mutual, 1979), 127–34; Balnave, “Industrial Welfarism,” 93. Google Scholar

21.NMLA, A Century of Life, 126. Google Scholar

22.Geoffrey Blainey, A History of the AMP, 1848–1998 (St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin, 1999), 329. Google Scholar

23.Sandy Grant, interview, 27 July 2015. Google Scholar

24.Monica Keneley, “The Development of the Institutional Investor: The Case of Australian Life Insurers 1945–85,” Australian Economic History Review 52 (2012): 270–92. Google Scholar

25.Bernard Mees, Monica Wehner and Pamela Hanrahan, Fifty Years of Managed Funds in Australia (Sydney: IFSA/Melbourne: University of Melbourne, 2005), 82–88. Google Scholar

26.James Miller Holdings Ltd v Graham and Ors (Vic), Australian Company Law Reports 3 (1978): 604; Greg Sword, quoted in “Both Sides Jittery on Super,” Age, 13 December 1985, 16. Google Scholar

27.Lawrence Coward, quoted in Peter Cairns, “He’s Workers’ ‘Super’ Man,” Herald, 29 March 1969, 21. Google Scholar

28.Jennifer Eastick, “James Miller Holdings Ltd v Graham and Others,” Melbourne University Law Review 12 (1979): 121–26. Google Scholar

29.Legislative Assembly, Victoria Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) 305 (18 November 1971): 2826–27. Google Scholar

30.Ray Jureidini, “Life Insurance and Superannuation: A Sociological Study of Moral Values in Economic Life” (PhD diss., Flinders University, 1987), 199–200. Google Scholar

31.Blainey, A History of the AMP, 281. Google Scholar

32.Peter Gebert, in An Oral History of C+BUS: The Construction and Building Industry’s Superannuation Fund, ed. Patricia Holt (Melbourne: National Centre for Australian Studies, Monash University, 1996), 48. Google Scholar

33.Phillip D. Jack, “Jacques Martin Grabs Union Business,” Australian Business, 12 March 1986, 34–35; Brendan Donohoe, “Life Companies Chasing Union Business,” Age, 22 May 1987, 55. Google Scholar

34.Minutes, Building Unions Superannuation, 29 May 1984, BUS Scheme N130/1052, NBAC. Google Scholar

35.Minutes, Building Unions Superannuation, 17 July 1984, BUS Scheme, N130/1052, NBAC. Google Scholar

36.Minutes, Building Unions Superannuation, 11 October 1984, BUS Scheme, N130/1054, NBAC. Google Scholar

37.William J. Kelty to insurance companies, 5 March 1984; Jacques Martin, tender, April 1984, and National Mutual, tender, April 1984, BUS Scheme, N130/1051, NBAC. Google Scholar

38.Victoria Government Gazette, no. 85 (19 August 1981): 2771; Ian Court, in Holt, Oral History of C+BUS, 16; Ian Court, interview, 18 November 2015; Weaven, “Workers’ Capital.” Google Scholar

39.Minutes, ACTU superannuation committee, 30 November 1979, box 234, Victorian Trades Hall Council collection, University of Melbourne Archives; John Benson, Cathy Brigden and Rhonda Smith, Union Response to Employment Instability: A Case Study of the Meat Industry (Parkville, Vic.: University of Melbourne, Dept. of Economics, 1985); Chris Northover, interview, 26 June 2015. Google Scholar

40.Dick Riley, “Union Super Scheme PLUS for Members,” The Liquor Trades Union Journal 2, no. 2 (1986); Colin Walker, “National Overview,” Australian Hotelier (March 1986), 12. Google Scholar

41.“Superannuation and You,” Australian Nursing Journal (June 1987): 11–12; Fiona Kyle, “National Superannuation Scheme Launch,” Australian Nursing Journal (September 1987): 14–15. Google Scholar

42.AMP to John P. Maynes, 16 April 1986, John Maynes papers, box 203, book 103, State Library of Victoria. Google Scholar

43.“Launch of State-wide Super Fund,” Australian Worker, 29 September 1987, 7; “Sunsuper Basks in the SGC,” Superfunds, April 1994, 25–27. Google Scholar

44.“ASSET” Australian Superannuation Savings Employment Trust, Newsletter, no. 2, 23 September 1987, John Maynes Papers, box 293, book 104, State Library of Victoria; “Profile: Neil Cassidy,” SuperTalk 17 (July 2015): 22. Google Scholar

45.Philippa Tyndale, “Industry Superannuation: Off the Boil, but Still Simmering,” Superfunds, November 1988, 40–43. Google Scholar

46.Hugh Pemberton, “‘What Matters is What Works’: Labour’s Journey from ‘National Superannuation’ to ‘Personal Accounts,’” British Politics 5, no. 1 (2010): 41–64. Google Scholar

47.House of Representatives, Parliamentary Debates (Hansard) 14 (5 April 1979): 1661–66. Google Scholar

48.Philip Chubb, “Cain Forces Landeryou Out,” Age, 1 September 1983, 1; M. E. J. Black, Advice to the Hon. John Cain, MP, Premier of Victoria, in the matter of the Honourable William Albert Landeryou, MLC, 25 October 1983, (Melbourne: Government Printer, 1983), 204–206. Google Scholar

49.Tom McDonald, interview, 23 March 2015. Google Scholar

50.John A. Ferguson, Report of the Royal Commission into the Compulsory Retirement of Employees in Coal and Oil Shale Mines in New South Wales at the Age of 60 Years (Sydney: Govt Printer, 1941); Coal and Oil Shale Mine Workers (Pensions) Act 1941 (NSW); A. Edward Woodward, National Stevedoring Industry Conference, General Report (Sydney 1967); Charlie Fitzgibbon to ACTU, 2 February 1977, Superannuation Unions N147/321, NBAC; Greg Sword, “The Storemen and Packers’ Union Superannuation Scheme,” in Finance of Old Age, ed. Ronald Mendelsohn (Canberra: ANU, 1986), 100; Margot Beasley, The Wharfies: A History of the Waterside Workers’ Federation of Australia (Rushcutters Bay: Halstead, 1996), 207–25; Northover, interview. Google Scholar

51.Brendan O’Donohoe, “Unions Step Closer to Super Goal,” Age, 16 December 1985, 1; Joe de Bruyn, interview, 7 April 2016. Google Scholar

52.Diana Shaw, “Trade Union and Worker Participation in the Control of Superannuation Funds,” in Democracy and Control in the Workplace, ed. Ed Davis and Russell Lansbury (Melbourne: Longman Cheshire, 1986), 192–215; Julian Teicher, “Employee Participation and Industrial Democracy in Australian Government Employment: 1983–1988” (PhD diss., Monash University, 1990). Google Scholar

53.Jureidini, “Life Insurance and Superannuation,” 41–49; Simon Cordery, British Friendly Societies, 1750–1914 (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2003), 29–41. Google Scholar

54.Beth Quinlivan, “Merging Industry Super Funds,” Superfunds, September 1992, 29–33. Google Scholar

55.Michael Easson, “Superannuation Funds and Investments: A Union View,” Superfunds, December 1986, 9–14; ACTU/TDC, Australia Reconstructed: ACTU/TDC Mission to Western Europe: A Report by the Mission Members to the ACTU and TDC (Canberra: AGPS, 1987). Google Scholar

56.Garry Weaven, report to ACTU Executive, 22 August 1988, John Maynes papers, box 200, folder 47, State Library of Victoria; Barrie Dunstan, “Socially Desirable Super Fund Aims to Raise $500m,” Australian Financial Review, 6 December 1990, 5. Google Scholar

59.“Women in Super: Background,” November 1993, AIST archives. Google Scholar

60.“Fitzgerald Uproots Superannuation Again,” Superfunds, October 1993, 9. Google Scholar

61.ALP/ACTU, “Accord Agreement 1993–1996: ‘Putting Jobs First’” (Accord Mark VII), March 1993; ACTU Executive decision, May 1994, Workplace (Winter 1994): 5; Cathy Bolt, “ACTU Enters Mortgage Market,” Australian Financial Review, 19 April 1994, 38. Google Scholar

62.Garry Weaven, “Discussion Paper: Opportunities for Property Investment,” June 1993, Workers’ Capital Project Archive, RMIT University; “Industry Funds’ Property Pool,” Superfunds, April 1994, 3; “Industry Funds Do It for Themselves,” Superfunds, July 1994, 3. Google Scholar

63.Court, interview. Google Scholar

64.Grant, interview. Google Scholar

65.Keneley, “Demise of the Mutual Life Insurer.” Google Scholar

66.Catherine Armitage, “MLC Swallows Capita,” Sydney Morning Herald, 19 April 1990, 30; Max Walsh, “Hoskins’ Burden: To Quell the Niggling,” Sydney Morning Herald, 28 May 1992, 33; Weaven, “Workers’ Capital.” Google Scholar

67.Garry Weaven, quoted in Barrie Dunstan, “Funds Body Looks for a Way to Diversify,” Australian Financial Review, 25 February 1999, 26. Google Scholar

68.Industry Fund Services, Report to Industry Superannuation Funds, September 2001, 4. Google Scholar

69.Ian Silk, interview, 10 August 2015; Louise Davidson, interview, 2 December 2015. Google Scholar

70.Maureen Murrill, “Jacques Martin Finally Goes Quietly with IFS,” Business Review Weekly, 29 September 1997, 49. Google Scholar

71.Silk, interview. Google Scholar

72.Christine St Anne, A Super History: How Australia’s 1 Trillion+ Superannuation Industry was Made (Melbourne: Major Street Publishing, 2012), 213–14. Google Scholar

73.Industry Fund Services, Report to Industry Superannuation Funds, August 2004, 6; Garry Weaven, “Mutualisation of Infrastructure: Using Superannuation to Provide our Future Needs” (paper presented to the Industry Super Australia, Innovation in Infrastructure: Beyond the G20 symposium, March 2015, National Portrait Gallery, Canberra). Google Scholar

74.Jeff Bresnahan, communication, 29 June 2016. Google Scholar

75.Bill Shorten, press release, 16 December 2010; Superannuation Legislation Amendment (MySuper Core Provisions) Act 2012 (Cth). Google Scholar

76.Reserve Bank of Australia, Financial Stability Review, March 2006, 52–53. Google Scholar

77.Ged Kearney, “Tragedy if Member-Owned Super Follows the Fate of Mutuals,” Australian Financial Review, 23 October 2015, 39. Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

 Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Mees, Bernard

Paul, Aron