British Journal of Canadian Studies

John Stuart Mill and the liberal idea of Canada

British Journal of Canadian Studies (2021), 33, (1), 31–46.

Abstract

The writer and politician John Stuart Mill played an important role in the two greatest constitutional moments of nineteenth-century Canada: he publicly supported Lord Durham’s 1838 report on Canada and he voted for the British North American Act (1867) that formed the Dominion of Canada. Mill had a part, in his own mind an important part, in Canada’s evolution from colony to self-governing dominion. I argue that his attitude to Canada was broadly consistent across these three decades and was consistent with his principled defence of liberal imperialism. But it was complicated by Mill’s relatively low opinion of the French Canadians who, he thought, lagged behind the rest of Canada in their development. That is why Mill supported Durham’s recommendation that they be assimilated into the English-speaking mainstream. I conclude that French Canada exposed the limits of Mill’s form of liberalism, which gave priority to the ‘civilising’ imperative over cultural diversity. And it remains questionable just how capacious Millian liberalism really is in accommodating cultural diversity.

L’écrivain et homme politique John Stuart Mill a joué un rôle important dans les deux plus grands moments constitutionnels du Canada au XIXe siècle : il a publiquement appuyé le rapport de 1838 de Lord Durham sur le Canada et il a voté pour l’Acte de l’Amérique du Nord britannique (1867) qui a formé le Dominion du Canada. Mill a joué un rôle, à son avis un rôle important, dans l’évolution du Canada de colonie à un dominion autonome. Je soutiens que son attitude à l’égard du Canada était globalement la même au cours de ces trois décennies et était conforme à sa défense de principe de l’impérialisme libéral. Mais cela a été compliqué par l’opinion relativement faible de Mill sur les Canadiens français qui, pensait-il, étaient à la traîne du reste du Canada dans leur développement. C’est la raison pour laquelle Mill a appuyé la recommandation de Durham d’être assimilés au grand public anglophone. Je conclus que le Canada français a exposé les limites de la forme de libéralisme de Mill, qui donnait la priorité à l’impératif « civilisateur » sur la diversité culturelle. Et on peut se demander à quel point le libéralisme millien est vraiment vaste pour accueillir la diversité culturelle.

Access Token
£25.00
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

References

Bell, Duncan, 2007, The Idea of Greater Britain: Empire and the Future of World Order, 1860-1900 (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press). Google Scholar

Bell, Duncan, 2010, ‘John Stuart Mill on Colonies’, Political Theory, 38:1, 34-64. Google Scholar

Capaldi, Nicholas, 2004, John Stuart Mill: A Biography (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Google Scholar

Collini, Stefan, 1985, ‘The Idea of Character in Victorian Political Thought’, Transactions of the Royal Historical Society, 35, 29-50. Google Scholar

Durham, 1st Earl of, James Lambton, 1839, Report on the Affairs of British North America from the Earl of Durham. Google Scholar

Filipiuk, Marion, 1991, ‘Mill and France’, in M. Laine (ed.), A Cultivated Mind: Essays on J.S. Mill Presented to John M. Robson (Toronto: University of Toronto Press). Google Scholar

Jahn, Beate, 2005, ‘Barbarian Thoughts: Imperialism in the Philosophy of John Stuart Mill’, Review of International Studies, 31, 599-619. Google Scholar

Kinzer, Bruce, 2001, England’s Disgrace? J.S. Mill and the Irish Question (Toronto and London: University of Toronto Press). Google Scholar

Kukathas, Chandran, 2003, The Liberal Archipelago: A Theory of Diversity and Freedom (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Google Scholar

Kymlicka, Will, 1989, Liberalism, Community, and Culture (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Google Scholar

Kymlicka, Will, 1992, ‘Two Models of Pluralism and Tolerance’, Analyse & Kritik, 13, 33-56. Google Scholar

Kymlicka, Will, 1995, Multicultural Citizenship: A Liberal Theory of Minority Rights (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Google Scholar

Larson, Timothy, 2018, John Stuart Mill: A Secular Life (Oxford: Oxford University Press). Google Scholar

Laxer, James, and Robert Laxer, 1977, The Liberal Idea of Canada: Pierre Trudeau and the Question of Canada’s Survival (Toronto: James Lorimer and Co). Google Scholar

Mehta, Uday, 1999, Liberalism and Empire: A Study in Nineteenth-Century British Liberal Thought (Chicago: University of Chicago Press). Google Scholar

Mill, John Stuart, 1963-91, The Collected Works of John Stuart Mill (ed. J.M. Robson et al.), 33 vols. (Toronto and London: University of Toronto Press). Google Scholar

Misra, Shefali, 2012, ‘Friend, Not Foe: Mill’s Liberal Multiculturalism’, European Journal of Political Theory, 11:3, 273-91. Google Scholar

Modood, Tariq, 2007, Multiculturalism: A Civic Idea (Cambridge: Polity Press). Google Scholar

Parekh, Bhikhu, 2000, Rethinking Multiculturalism: Cultural Diversity and Political Theory (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press). Google Scholar

Phillips, Paul, 2002, The Controversialist: An Intellectual Life of Goldwin Smith (Westport, CT and London: Praeger). Google Scholar

Pitts, Jennifer, 2005, A Turn to Empire: The Rise of Imperial Liberalism in Britain and France (Princeton and Oxford: Princeton University Press). Google Scholar

Reeves, Richard, 2007, John Stuart Mill: Victorian Firebrand (London: Atlantic Books). Google Scholar

Sandel, Michael, 1982, Liberalism and the Limits of Justice (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). Google Scholar

Smith, Goldwin, 1877, Political Destiny of Canada (Toronto: Belford Brothers). Google Scholar

Smith, Goldwin, 1893, ‘Anglo-Saxon Union: A Response to Mr Carnegie’, North American Review, 157, 178. Google Scholar

Varouxakis, Georgios, 1998, ‘National Character in John Stuart Mill’s Thought’, History of European Ideas, 24:6, 375-91. Google Scholar

Varouxakis, Georgios, 2004, ‘French Radicalism through the Eyes of John Stuart Mill’, History of European Ideas, 30, 433-61. Google Scholar

Zastoupil, Lynn, 1994, John Stuart Mill and India (Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Garrard, Graeme