British Journal of Canadian Studies

Québec’s new regional fiction: Louise Penny and Johanne Seymour

British Journal of Canadian Studies (2021), 33, (2), 225–240.


Louise Penny’s Still Life (2005) and Johanne Seymour’s Le Cri du cerf (2005) are both murder mysteries set in the Eastern Townships, in south-eastern and south-central Québec. Much of the region borders the United States. To varying degrees, the border makes its presence felt in the novels by Penny and Seymour, along with other landmarks familiar to domestic audiences. This article argues that the apparent situatedness of the texts is, however, challenged by their adherence to the formal conventions of the murder mystery and associated subgenres. In so doing, it claims that Still Life and Le Cri du cerf foster multi-layered readings which, in bringing together the hyper-local and the international, prompt a reconsideration of understandings of regional fiction.

L’action des romans policiers, Still Life (2005) de Louise Penny et Le Cri du cerf (2005) de Johanne Seymour se situe dans les Cantons-de-l’Est, dans le sud-est et le sud-central du Québec. Une grande partie de la région borde les États-Unis. La présence de la frontière se fait sentir dans les deux romans, ainsi que d’autres points de repère bien connus du lectorat québécois. Cet article propose que cet ancrage apparent dans le régional se trouve contesté par l’adhérence de ces textes aux conventions formelles du roman policier et ses sous-genres. Still Life et Le Cri du cerf inviteraient ainsi à des lectures aux niveaux multiples mettant en dialogue l’hyperlocal et l’international et provoquant du même coup une remise en question des conceptions de la fiction régionale.

Access Token
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here


Agnant, Marie-Célie, 2002, Le Livre d’Emma (Montréal: les Éditions du remue-ménage). Google Scholar

Benazon, Michael, 2007, ‘The Decline and Fall of the Athens of the North: Literary Production in the Eastern Townships’, in Jason Camlot and Todd Swift (eds), Language Acts: Anglo-Québec Poetry 1976 to the 21st Century (Montréal: Véhicule Press, 2007), pp. 194-201. Google Scholar

Bishop, Nicola, 2018, ‘Rural Nostalgia: Revisiting the Lost Idyll in British Library Crime Classics Detective Fiction’, Green Letters: Studies in Ecocriticism, 22:1, 31-42. Google Scholar

Blunt, Giles, 2000, Forty Words for Sorrow (New York: Penguin Random House). Google Scholar

Bon Cop, Bad Cop (Erik Canuel, 2006). Google Scholar

Bonjourquebec, (accessed 19 February 2021). Google Scholar

The Bridge (2013-14). Google Scholar

Bron/Broen (2011-18). Google Scholar

Cardinal (2017-20). Google Scholar

Coupal, Denis, 2019, Blindshot (Montréal: Linda Leith Publishing). Google Scholar

Davidson, Arnold E., 1981, ‘Canadian Gothic and Anne Hébert’s Kamouraska’, Modern Fiction Studies, 27:2 (Summer), 243-54. Google Scholar

Deliverance (John Boorman, 1972). Google Scholar

Esrock, Robin, ‘Eastern Townships’, (accessed 20 February 2021). Google Scholar

Flynn, Gillian, 2012, Gone Girl (New York: Crown Publishers). Google Scholar

Fortin, Andrée, and Carole Després, 2011, ‘Étalement urbain et développement durable: enjeux et défis’, in Andrée Fortin, Carole Després and Geneviève Vachon (eds), La Banlieue s’étale (Québec: Éditions Nota bene), pp. 13-34. Google Scholar

Gelder, Ken, 2016, ‘Introduction: The Fields of Popular Fiction, in Ken Gelder (ed.), New Directions in Popular Fiction: Genre, Distribution, Reproduction (London: Palgrave), pp. 10-14. Google Scholar

Hage, Rawi, 2008, Cockroach (Toronto: Anansi). Google Scholar

Hébert, Anne, 1982, Les Fous de bassan (Paris: Seuil). Google Scholar

Hinterland (2013-). Google Scholar

Holdsworth, Clare, 2020, ‘The Paradoxical Habits of Busyness and the Complexity of Intimate Time-Space’, Social & Cultural Geography, doi: 10.1080/14649365.2020.1769167. Google Scholar

Jones, Manina, 2020, ‘Canadian Noir: Consumer Culture, Colonial Nationalism and the Cardinal Series’, Forum for Modern Language Studies, 56:3, 280-94. Google Scholar

Keightley, Liane, 2007, ‘Inlet’, ‘Triton and Tex’, in Seven Openings of the Head (Montréal: Conundrum Press), pp. 57-67, pp. 101-28. Google Scholar

Keil, Roger, and Jean-Paul Addie, 2016, ‘“It’s Not going to be Surburban, It’s Going to be All Urban”: Assembling Post-suburbia in the Toronto and Chicago Regions’, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 39:5, 892-911. Google Scholar

The Killing (2011-14). Google Scholar

Laferrière, Dany, 1985, Comment faire l’amour avec un Nègre sans se fatiguer (Montréal: vlb). Google Scholar

Langer, Beryl, 2014, ‘Coca-Colonials Write Back: Localizing the Global in Canadian Crime Fiction’, in Jeannette Sloniowski and Marilyn Rose (eds), Detecting Canada: Essays on Canadian Crime Fiction, Television and Film (Waterloo: Wilfrid Laurier University Press), Kindle Edition. Google Scholar

Laperrière, Guy, 2009, Les Cantons-de-l’Est (Québec: Presses de l’Université Laval). Google Scholar

Lapierre, Hélène, 2014, Les Barricades (Montréal: Québec/Amérique). Google Scholar

Leclerc, Catherine, 2010, Des langues en partage? Cohabitation du français et de l’anglais en littérature contemporaine (Montréal: XYZ). Google Scholar

Louisepenny, (accessed 19 February 2021). Google Scholar

Malmgren, Carl D., 1997, ‘Anatomy of Murder: Mystery, Detective, and Crime Fiction’, Journal of Popular Culture, 30:4, 115-35. Google Scholar

Mann, J. Debbie, 2020, ‘The World(s) of Three Pines: Creating Community in the Novels of Louise Penny’, Journal of Eastern Townships Studies, 48, 13-24. Google Scholar

Massey, Doreen, 2004, ‘Geographies of Responsibility’, Geografiska Annaler: Series B, Human Geography, 86:1, 5-18. Google Scholar

Michaud, Andrée A., 2014, Bondrée (Montréal: Québec/Amérique). Google Scholar

Moore, Jeffrey, 2010, The Extinction Club (Toronto: Hamish Hamilton). Google Scholar

Morgan, Ceri, 2017, Writing, Talking and Walking Québec’s Eastern Townships (London: Eccles Centre for American Studies). Google Scholar

Morgan, Ceri, 2019, ‘Introduction: ’Urbs: Suburban and Exurban Spaces in Québec and Francophone Canada’, Quebec Studies, 68, 55-8. Google Scholar

Nepveu, Pierre, and Gilles Marcotte, 1992, ‘Introduction: Montréal, sa littérature’, dans Nepveu et Marcotte (ed.), Montréal imaginaire: ville et littérature (Montréal: Fides), pp. 7-11. Google Scholar

Oliver, Catherine, 2020, ‘Cozies, Capers and Other Criminal Endeavours: Utilizing Taxonomies of Mystery Fiction to Improve Genre Access’, Library Resources & Technical Services, 64:4, 152-64. Google Scholar

Ozark (2017-). Google Scholar

Penny, Louise, 2005, Still Life (London: Headline). Google Scholar

Plomer, Michèle, 2013 [2011-13], 3 vol., Dragonville (Montréal: Marchand de feuilles). Google Scholar

Roberts, Gillian, and David Stirrup, 2013, ‘Introduction: Culture at the 49th Parallel: Nationalism, Indigeneity, and the Hemispheric’, in Gillian Roberts and David Stirrup (eds), Parallel Encounters: Culture and the Canada-US Border (Waterloo, ON: Wilfrid Laurier University Press), pp. 1-24. Google Scholar

Seymour, Johanne, 2005, Le Cri du cerf (Outremont: Libre expression). Google Scholar

Sheehan, Dan, 2016, ‘Donald Ray Pollock’s Gothic Hillbilly Noir’, Electric Lit, 25 July, (accessed 20 February 2021). Google Scholar

Sicario (Denis Villeneuve, 2015). Google Scholar

Simon, Sherry, 2012, Cities in Translation: Intersections of Language and Memory (London: Routledge). Google Scholar

Sloniowski, Jeannette, and Marilyn Rose, 2014, ‘Introduction’, in Detecting Canada (Waterloo, ON: Wilfrid Laurier University Press). Kindle Edition. Google Scholar

Warriar, Nalini, 2005, The Enemy Within (Toronto: Tsar). Google Scholar

Woodrell, Daniel, 2006, Winter’s Bone (New York: Little, Brown and Company). Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here


Author details

Morgan, Ceri