International Development Planning Review

E-musrenbang: a digital framework for local participatory planning at the community level

International Development Planning Review Ahead of print, 1–26.


It has been a longstanding mission of policymakers, good governance activists and scholars to encourage greater public participation in formulating legal drafts for better city planning. In recent years, emphasis has been placed upon digital engagement as a process which arguably allows more citizens to voice their needs and desires. In Indonesia, an example of such practices can be seen in the e-musrenbang platform, a digital version of a local public participation mechanism in city planning. This study highlights the case of Bandung City of Indonesia by shedding light on the implemented mechanism of e-musrenbang and the stakeholders involved as well as perceptions from its participants. The findings suggest that e-musrenbang has enhanced the transparency and accountability of the overall planning process, however, it has failed to deliver on promises to channel the voices of citizens and solve existing issues of participation.

Access Token
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here


Akbar, G. G., Kania, I., Ulumudin, A., Anggadwita, G., Harmanto, L. S. and Alamanda, D. T. (2019) ‘Innovation in the public sector: the effectiveness of “LAPOR!” as one of the smart city programs in Bandung’, in S. Kusmana, I. Rosnidah, A. G. Abdullah, H. Budiana and S. Khumayah (eds), International Symposium on Social Sciences, Education, and Humanities (ISSEH 2018), Amsterdam, Atlantis Press, 297-302. Google Scholar

Alawadi, K. and Dooling, S. (2016) ‘Challenges and opportunities for participatory planning approaches within Dubai’s urban context’, Journal of Urbanism: International Research on Place-making and Urban Sustainability, 9(3), 276-301. Google Scholar

Alexandri, M. B. and Raharja, S. J. (2020) ‘Development strategy of Bandung creative city through the performance improvement of creative industries’, International Journal of Business and Globalisation, 24(4), 560-568. Google Scholar

Alfasi, N. (2004) ‘Public participation and the democratization of urban planning’, Horizons in Geography / היפרגואגב םיקפוא, (60/61), 21-28. Google Scholar

Alizadeh, T., Sarkar, S. and Burgoyne, S. (2019) ‘Capturing citizen voice online: enabling smart participatory local government’, Cities, 95, 102400. Google Scholar

Angeline, M., Evelina, L. and Siregar, V. M. (2016) ‘Towards cyber city: DKI Jakarta and Surabaya provincial government digital public services’, Humaniora, 7(4), 441-451. Google Scholar

Anindito, D. B. and Sutriadi, R. (2016) ‘Towards a just city in information era: understanding the inclusiveness of community network induced by telecommunication technology at the local level (Case study: Cihapit and Cipaganti neighborhoods, Bandung City, Indonesia)’, Procedia: Social and Behavioral Sciences, 227, 255-264. Google Scholar

Arnstein, S. R. (1969) ‘A ladder of citizen participation’, Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 35(4), 216-224. Google Scholar

Baiocchi, G. (2015) ‘But who will speak for the people? The travel and translation of participatory budgeting’, in G. Baiocchi (ed.), Deliberation and Development: Rethinking the Role of Voice and Collective Action in Unequal Societies, Washington, DC, World Bank, 107-132. Google Scholar

Bintari, A. and Akbar, I. (2017) ‘Collaborative planning in policy-making process in Bandung City’, in Unhas International Conference on Social and Political Science (UICoSP 2017), Amsterdam, Atlantis Press, 30-33. Google Scholar

Bobbio, L. (2019) ‘Designing effective public participation’, Policy and Society, 38(1), 41-57. Google Scholar

Brabham, D. C. (2008) ‘Crowdsourcing as a model for problem solving: an introduction and cases’, Convergence: The International Journal of Research into New Media Technologies, 14(1), 75-90. Google Scholar

Brabham, D. C. (2009) ‘Crowdsourcing the public participation process for planning projects’, Planning Theory, 8(3), 242-262. Google Scholar

Brabham, D. C. (2012) ‘Motivations for participation in a crowdsourcing application to improve public engagement in transit planning’, Journal of Applied Communication Research, 40(3), 307-328. Google Scholar

Brown, G. and Kyttä, M. (2014) ‘Key issues and research priorities for public participation GIS (PPGIS): a synthesis based on empirical research’, Applied Geography, 46, 122-136. Google Scholar

Bugs, G., Granell, C., Fonts, O, Huerta, J. and Painho, M. (2010) ‘An assessment of public participation GIS and Web 2.0 technologies in urban planning practice in Canela, Brazil’, Cities, 27(3), 172-181. Google Scholar

Bunnell, T. (2015) ‘Antecedent cities and inter-referencing effects: learning from and extending beyond critiques of neoliberalisation’, Urban Studies, 52(11), 1983-2000. Google Scholar

Bunnell, T. G. and Coe, N. M. (2001) ‘Spaces and scales of innovation’, Progress in Human Geography, 25(4), 569-589. Google Scholar

Caird, S. (2018) ‘City approaches to smart city evaluation and reporting: case studies in the United Kingdom’, Urban Research & Practice, 11(2), 159-179. Google Scholar

Cardullo, P. and Kitchin, R. (2018) ‘Being a “citizen” in the smart city: up and down the scaffold of smart citizen participation in Dublin, Ireland’, GeoJournal, 84(1), 1-13. Google Scholar

Carver, S., Evans, A., Kingston, R. and Turton, I. (2001) ‘Public participation, GIS, and cyber-democracy: evaluating on-line spatial decision support systems’, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 28(6), 907-921. Google Scholar

Chess, C. and Purcell, K. (1999) ‘Public participation and the environment: do we know what works?’, Environmental Science & Technology, 33(16), 2685-2692. Google Scholar

Conrad, E., Cassar, L. F., Jones, M., Eiter, S., Izaovičová, Z., Barankova, Z., Christie, M. and Fazey, I. (2011) ‘Rhetoric and reporting of public participation in landscape policy’, Journal of Environmental Policy & Planning, 13(1), 23-47. Google Scholar

Conroy, M. M. and Evans-Cowley, J. (2006) ‘E-participation in planning: an analysis of cities adopting on-line citizen participation tools’, Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy, 24(3), 371-384. Google Scholar

Dewi, K. C., Ciptayani, P. I. and Wijaya, I. W. R. (2018) ‘Agile project management pada pengembangan e-musrenbang kelurahan benoa Bali’, Jurnal Teknologi Informasi dan Ilmu Komputer (JTIIK) 5(6), 723-730. Google Scholar

Dhewanto, W., Lantu, D. C., Herliana, S. and Anggadwita, G. (2015) ‘The innovation cluster of ICT start-up companies in developing countries: case of Bandung, Indonesia’, International Journal of Learning and Intellectual Capital, 12(1), 32-46. Google Scholar

Fitrat, I. (2017) ‘E-Musrenbang Perkuat Smart City Bandung’, 3 February, Republika, (accessed 18 June 2020). Google Scholar

Franceschini, S. and Marletto, G. E. (2019) ‘The dynamics of trust during public participation’, Papers in Regional Science, 98(4), 1713-1729. Google Scholar

Fung, A. (2006) ‘Varieties of participation in complex governance’, Public Administration Review, 66(s1), 66-75. Google Scholar

Fung, A., Gilman, H. R. and Shkabatur, J. (2015) ‘Technology for democracy in development: lessons from seven case studies’, in A. Fung, H. R. Gilman and J. Shkabatur (eds), Deliberation and Development: Rethinking the Role of Voice and Collective Action in Unequal Societies, Washington, DC, World Bank, 229-236. Google Scholar

Ghose, R, (2007) ‘Politics of scale and networks of association in public participation GIS’, Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 39(8), 1961-1980. Google Scholar

Heipke, C. (2010) ‘Crowdsourcing geospatial data’, ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing, 65(6), 550-557. Google Scholar

Hollands, R. G. (2008) ‘Will the real smart city please stand up? Intelligent, progressive or entrepreneurial?’ City 12(3), 303-320, Google Scholar

Hudalah, D. and Woltjer, J. (2007) ‘Spatial planning system in transitional Indonesia’, International Planning Studies, 12(3), 291-303. Google Scholar

Hudson-Smith, A., Batty, M., Crooks, A. and Milton, R. (2009) ‘Mapping for the masses: accessing web 2.0 through crowdsourcing’, Social Science Computer Review, 27(4), 524-538. Google Scholar

Jamilah, I., Akbar, K. F., Gunawan, M. A. and Marantika, S. (2016) ‘Political communication, social media, and public sphere: an analysis to a phenomenon in Bandung towards smart city’, International Journal of Social Science and Humanity, 6(12), 923-928. Google Scholar

Jankowski, P., Czepkiewicz, M., Młodkowski, M., Zwoliński, Z. and Wójcicki. M. (2019) ‘Evaluating the scalability of public participation in urban land use planning: a comparison of Geoweb methods with face-to-face meetings’, Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, 46(3), 511-533. Google Scholar

Jeffres, L. W. (2010) ‘The communicative city: conceptualizing, operationalizing, and policy making’, Journal of Planning Literature, 25(2), 99-110. Google Scholar

Kahila-Tani, M., Kytta, M. and Geertman, S. (2019) ‘Does mapping improve public participation? Exploring the pros and cons of using public participation GIS in urban planning practices’, Landscape and Urban Planning, 186, 45-55. Google Scholar

King, C. S., Feltey, K. M. and Susel, B. O. (1998) ‘The question of participation: toward authentic public participation in public administration’, Public Administration Review, 58(4), 317-326. Google Scholar

Kurniasih, D. (2010) ‘Model skala prioritas pembangunan kota Bandung berbasis good governance’, Makara Seri SosialHumaniora 9(2), 72-83, Google Scholar

Kusumawardani R. P., Rakhmawati N. A., Wibowo R. P., Irmasari, H. and Pranatha, D. (2015) ‘A prototype of MonVis-Musrenbang: monitoring and visualization application for Surabaya Development Plan’, Information Systems International Conference, 2015. Google Scholar

Lee, Y. and Schachter, H. L. (2019) ‘Exploring the relationship between trust in government and citizen participation’, International Journal of Public Administration, 42(5), 405-416. Google Scholar

Mandarano, L., Meenar, M. and Steins, C. (2010) ‘Building social capital in the digital age of civic engagement’, Journal of Planning Literature, 25(2), 123-135. Google Scholar

Masbuhin, A. T., Alim, M. N. and Tarjo, T. (2017) ‘The phenomenon of musrenbang in terms of local wisdom: an effort to prevent corruption in the local government’, Asia Pacific Fraud Journal, 3(2), 365-373. Google Scholar

Meijer, A. J., Curtin, D. and Hillebrandt, M. (2012) ‘Open government: connecting vision and voice’, International Review of Administrative Sciences, 78(1), 10-29. Google Scholar

Menon, S, and Hartz-Karp, J. (2019) ‘Institutional innovations in public participation for improved local governance and urban sustainability in India’, Sustainable Earth, 2(1), 6. Google Scholar

Mihelj, S., Leguina, A. and Downey, J. (2019) ‘Culture is digital: cultural participation, diversity and the digital divide’, New Media & Society, 21(7), 1465-1485. Google Scholar

Møller, M. S., Olafsson, A. S., Vierikko, K., Sehested, K., Elands, B., Buijs, A. and van den Bosch, C. K. (2019) ‘Participation through place-based e-tools: a valuable resource for urban green infrastructure governance?’, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening, 40, 245-253. Google Scholar

Morrell, E., Tuerah, N. and Sumarto, H. S. (2011) ‘Local authority and pro-poor urban management in Indonesia’s transition to democracy’, International Development Planning Review, 33(1), 49-66. Google Scholar

Mursalim, S. W. (2018) ‘Analisis Manajemen Pengaduan Sistem Layanan Sistem Aspirasi Pengaduan Online Rakyat (LAPOR) di Kota Bandung’, Jurnal Ilmu Administrasi: Media Pengembangan Ilmu dan Praktek Administrasi, 15(1), 1-17. Google Scholar

Obermayr, C. (2017) Sustainable City Management: Informal Settlements in Surakarta, Indonesia, Cham, Springer. Google Scholar

Offenhuber, D. (2019) ‘The platform and the bricoleur: improvisation and smart city initiatives in Indonesia’, Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, 46(8), 1565-1580. Google Scholar

Phelps, N. A., Bunnell, T., Miller, M. A. and Taylor, J. (2014) ‘Urban inter-referencing within and beyond a decentralized Indonesia’, Cities, 39, 37-49. Google Scholar

Plein, L. C., Green, K. E. and Williams, D. G. (1998) ‘Organic planning: a new approach to public participation in local governance’, The Social Science Journal, 35(4), 509-523. Google Scholar

Pløger, J. (2001) ‘Public participation and the art of governance’, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 28(2), 219-241. Google Scholar

Reynolds, J. P. (1969) ‘Public participation in planning’, The Town Planning Review, 40(2), 131-148. Google Scholar

Rowe, G. and Frewer, L. J. (2000) ‘Public participation methods: a framework for evaluation’, Science, Technology, & Human Values, 25(1), 3-29. Google Scholar

Royo, S. and Yetano, A. (2015) ‘“Crowdsourcing” as a tool for e-participation: two experiences regarding CO2 emissions at municipal level’, Electronic Commerce Research, 15(3), 323-348. Google Scholar

Rydin, Y. and Pennington, M. (2000) ‘Public participation and local environmental planning: the collective action problem and the potential of social capital’, Local Environment 5(2), 153-169. Google Scholar

Seltzer, E. and Mahmoudi, D. (2013) ‘Citizen participation, open innovation, and crowd-sourcing: challenges and opportunities for planning’, Journal of Planning Literature, 28(1), 3-18. Google Scholar

Shkabatur, J. (2010) ‘Cities at crossroads: digital technology and local democracy in America’, Brooklyn Law Review, 76, 1413. Google Scholar

Siahaan, A. Y. and Sihombing, T. (2017) ‘Implementing e-public service in North Sumatera: prospects and challenges’, in A. Siahaan, T. Sihombing, R. Shaw, T. Jakimow and B. Sumintono (eds), International Conference on Public Policy, Social Computing and Development 2017 (ICOPOSDev 2017), Amsterdam, Atlantis Press, 181-184. Google Scholar

Sindre, G. M. (2017) ‘Civic engagement and democracy in post-Suharto Indonesia: a review of Musrenbang, the Kecamatan Development Programme, and Labour Organising’, PCD Journal, 4(1-2): 1-40. Google Scholar

Sitinjak, E., Meidityawati, B., Ichwan, R., Onggosandojo, N. and Aryani, P. (2018) ‘Enhancing urban resilience through technology and social media: case study of urban Jakarta’, Procedia Engineering, 212, 222-229. Google Scholar

Smith, L. G. (1982) ‘Mechanisms for public participation at a normative planning level in Canada’, Canadian Public Policy / Analyse de Politiques, 8(4), 561-572. Google Scholar

Sofhani, T. F. (2005) ‘Community participation in Indonesia development policy: neo-liberal and post-Marxism prespective’, Journal of Regional and City Planning, 16(1), 56-68. Google Scholar

Sopanah, A. (2012) ‘Ceremonial budgeting: public participation in development planning at an Indonesian local government authority’, Journal of Applied Management Accounting Research, 10(2), 73-84. Google Scholar

Stern, E., Gudes, O. and Svoray, T. (2009) ‘Web-based and traditional public participation in comprehensive planning: a comparative study’, Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design, 36(6), 1067-1085. Google Scholar

Talitha, T., Firman, T. and Hudalah, D. (2019) ‘Welcoming two decades of decentralization in Indonesia: a regional development perspective’, Territory, Politics, Governance, Google Scholar

Tarigan, A. K. M., Sagala, S., Samsura, D. A. A., Fiisabiilillah, D. F., Simarmata, H. A. and Nababan, M. (2016) ‘Bandung City, Indonesia’, Cities, 50, 100-110. Google Scholar

Tarigan, A. K. M., Samsura, D. A. A., Sagala, S. and Pencawan, A. V. M. (2017) ‘Medan City: development and governance under the decentralisation era’, Cities, 71, 135-146. Google Scholar

Widianingsih, I. and Morrell, D. E. (2007) ‘Participatory planning in Indonesia’, Policy Studies, 28(1): 1-15. Google Scholar

Widyanarko, P. A. (2018) ‘The use of social media and open data in promoting civic co-management: case of Jakarta’, IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 158, Conference 1, (accessed 10 June 2019). Google Scholar

Yujin, K. (2017) ‘Making “creative” movement: transformation of urban culture and politics in Bandung, Indonesia’, Geographical Review of Japan Series B, 90(1), 17-25. Google Scholar

Yunas, N. S. (2017) ‘Efektivitas E-Musrenbang di Kota Surabaya dalam Sistem Perencanaan Pembangunan Berparadigma Masyarakat’, Otoritas : Jurnal Ilmu Pemerintahan, 7(1), 19-27. Google Scholar

Zhang, S. (2019) ‘Public participation in the Geoweb era: defining a typology for geo-participation in local governments’, Cities, 85, 38-50. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here


Author details

Anindito, Dhimas Bayu

Sagala, Saut A. H.

Tarigan, Ari Krisna Mawira