Town Planning Review

Effects of new construction and renovation on ethnic and social mixing in apartment buildings in Estonia

Town Planning Review (2022), 93, (4), 373–400.

Abstract

Residential segregation between social groups has grown in European cities, while the housing sector has boomed in major cities since 2009. These two forces raise questions about the role of new housing construction in the growth of segregation. This article explores the sorting of both socio-economic and ethnic groups into three housing types: older, newer and renovated apartment buildings. We employ data from Tallinn, the capital city of Estonia, where new housing construction has been extensive during the past ten years. We link census data with building-level data for publicly subsidised and privately funded housing renovations, and we calculate segregation indices by housing type and construct a multinomial regression model. Results suggest that publicly subsidised housing renovation contributes to continued mixing of socio-economic (occupational) groups, while new housing construction and especially private renovation increase segregation between ethnic and occupational groups. Ethnic and occupational segregation interact most strongly in privately funded apartment building renovations primarily within central city historic neighbourhoods.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

References

AHAS, R., MOOSES, V., KAMENJUK, P. and TAMM, R. (2019), ‘Retrofitting Soviet-era apartment buildings with “smart city” features: the H2020 SmartEnCity project in Tartu, Estonia’, in Hess and Tammaru (eds), 357-75. Google Scholar

ALLEN, J. (2006), ‘Welfare regimes, welfare systems and housing in Southern Europe’, International Journal of Housing Policy, 6, 251-77. Google Scholar

ANDERSSON, E. K., MALMBERG, B., COSTA, R., SLEUTJES, B., STONAWSKI, M. J. and DE VALK, H. A. (2018), ‘A comparative study of segregation patterns in Belgium, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden: neighbourhood concentration and representation of non-European migrants’, European Journal of Population, 34, 251-75. Google Scholar

ANDERSSON, R. and KÃHRIK, A. (2016), ‘Widening gaps: segregation dynamics during two decades of economic and institutional change in Stockholm’, in T. Tammaru, M. van Ham, M. Marcińczak and S. Musterd (eds), Socio-economic Segregation in European Capitals: East Meets West, London, Routledge, 110-31. Google Scholar

ARBACI, S. (2008), ‘(Re)Viewing ethnic segregation in Southern European cities: housing and urban regimes as mechanisms of marginalisation’, Housing Studies, 23, 589-613. Google Scholar

BERNELIUS, V., HUILLA, H.and LOBATO, I. R. (2021), ‘“Notorious schools” in “notorious places”? Exploring the connectedness of urban and educational segregation’, Social Inclusion, 9, 154-65. Google Scholar

BERNT, M. (2016), ‘How post-socialist is gentrification? Observations in East Berlin and Saint Petersburg’, Eurasian Geography and Economics, 57, 565-87. Google Scholar

BLUMENSTOCK, J., TOOMET, O., AHAS, R. and SALUVEER, E. (2015), ‘Neighborhood and network segregation: ethnic homophily in a silently separate society’ (proceedings of the NetMob Conference, 8-10 April 2015, Massachusetts, United States). Google Scholar

BOLT, G. and VAN KEMPEN, R. (2010), ‘Ethnic segregation and residential mobility: relocations of minority ethnic groups in the Netherlands’, Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies, 36, 333-54. Google Scholar

BOLT, G., PHILLIPS, D. and VAN KEMPEN, R. (2010), ‘Housing policy, (de)segregation and social mixing: An international perspective’, Housing Studies, 25, 129-35. Google Scholar

BOTERMAN, W., MUSTERD, S., PACCHI, C. and RANCI, C. (2019), ‘School segregation in contemporary cities: socio-spatial dynamics, institutional context and urban outcomes’, Urban Studies, 56, 3055-73. Google Scholar

BUIS, M. (2010), ‘The consequences of unobserved heterogeneity in a sequential logit model’, Research in Social Stratification and Mobility, 29, 247-62. Google Scholar

BRÅMÅ, Å. (2006), ‘“White flight”? The production and reproduction of immigrant concentration areas in Swedish cities, 1990-2000”, Urban Studies, 43, 1127-46. Google Scholar

CROWDER, K., SOUTH, S. J. and CHAVEZ, E. (2006), ‘Wealth, race, and inter-neighborhood migration’, American Sociological Review, 71, 72-94. Google Scholar

DEWILDE, C. and DE DECKER, P. (2016), ‘Changing inequalities in housing outcomes across Western Europe’, Housing, Theory and Society, 33, 121-61. Google Scholar

ELLIS, M., HOLLOWAY, S. R., WRIGHT, R. and FOWLER, C. S. (2012), ‘Agents of change: mixed-race households and the dynamics of neighborhood segregation in the United States’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 102, 549-70. Google Scholar

FLORIDA, R. and MELLANDER, C. (2015), ‘Segregated city: the geography of economic segregation in America’s metros’, Martin Prosperity Institute. Google Scholar

FRIESENECKER, M. and KAZEPOV, Y. (2021), ‘Housing Vienna: the socio-spatial effects of inclusionary and exclusionary mechanisms of housing provision’, Social Inclusion, 9, 77-90. Google Scholar

GENTILE, M., TAMMARU, T. and VAN KEMPEN, R. (2012), ‘Heteropolitanization: social and spatial change in Central and East European cities’, Cities, 29, 291-99. Google Scholar

GLIKMAN, A. and SEMOYONOV, M. (2012), ‘Ethnic origin and residential attainment of immigrants in European countries’, City & Community, 11, 198-219. Google Scholar

HAASE, A., GROSSMANN, K. and STEINFÜHRER, A. (2012), ‘Transitory urbanites: new actors of residential change in Polish and Czech inner cities’, Cities, 29, 318-26. Google Scholar

HEGEDÜS, J. (2013), ‘The transformation of the social housing sector in Eastern Europe: a conceptual framework’, in J. Hegedüs, M. Lux and N. Teller (eds), Social Housing in Transition Countries, London and New York, Routledge, 1-32. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. (2011), ‘Early 20th-century tenement buildings in Estonia: building blocks for neighborhood longevity’, Town Planning and Architecture, 35, 110-16. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. (2017), ‘Transport in Mikrorayons: accessibility and proximity to centrally planned residential districts during the socialist era, 1957-1989’, Journal of Planning History, 17, 184-204. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. and HIOB, M. (2014), ‘Preservation by neglect in Soviet-era town planning in Tartu, Estonia’, Journal of Planning History, 13, 24-49. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B., IACOBUCCI, E. and VÄIKO, A. (2017), ‘Network connections and neighbourhood perception: using social media postings to capture attitudes among twitter users in Estonia’, Architecture & Urban Planning, 13, 67-78. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. and TAMMARU, T. (eds) (2019a), Housing Estates in the Baltic Countries: The Legacy of Central Planning in Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania, Dordrecht, Springer. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B. and TAMMARU, T. (2019b), ‘Modernist housing estates in the Baltic countries: formation, current challenges and future prospects’, in Hess and Tammaru (eds), 3-27. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B., TAMMARU, T. and LEETMAA, K. (2012), ‘Ethnic differences in housing in post-Soviet Tartu, Estonia’, Cities, 29, 327-33. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B., TAMMARU, T. and VAN HAM, M. (eds), (2018a), Housing Estates in Europe: Poverty, Ethnic Segregation, and Policy Challenges, Dordrecht, Springer. Google Scholar

HESS, D. B., TAMMARU, T. and VAN HAM, M. (2018b), ‘Lessons learned from a pan-European study of large housing estates: origin, trajectories of change, and future prospects’, in Hess et al. (eds), 3-31. Google Scholar

HOCHSTENBACH, C. and MUSTERD, S. (2018), ‘Gentrification and the suburbanization of poverty: changing urban geographies through boom and bust periods’, Urban Geography, 39, 26-53. Google Scholar

HOLVANDUS, J., PASTAK, I., LEETMAA, K. and TAMMARU, T. (2015), ‘Report 2m fieldwork inhabitants, Tallinn (Estonia)’, Tartu, University of Tartu, https://www.urbandivercities.eu/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Estonia_WP6_final_report.pdf (accessed 11 December 2017). Google Scholar

HULCHANSKI, D. (2010), The Three Cities within Toronto: Income Polarization among Toronto’s Neighbourhoods, 1970-2005, Toronto, University of Toronto Press. Google Scholar

KABISCH, S. and GROSSMANN, K. (2013), ‘Challenges for large housing estates in light of population decline and ageing: results of a long-term survey in East Germany’, Habitat International, 39, 232-39. Google Scholar

KÄHRIK, A., KANGUR, K. and LEETMAA, K. (2019), ‘Socio-economic and ethnic trajectories of housing estates in Tallinn, Estonia’, in Hess and Tammaru (eds), 203-23. Google Scholar

KÄHRIK, A. and TAMMARU, T. (2010), ‘Soviet prefabricated panel housing estates: areas of continued social mix or decline? The case of Tallinn’, Housing Studies, 25, 201-19. Google Scholar

KÖÖTS-AUSMEES, L. and REALO, A. (2016), ‘Life satisfaction among ethnic minorities in Europe’, Journal of Cross-cultural Psychology, 47, 457-78. Google Scholar

KORCELLI-OLEJNICZAK, E. and TAMMARU, T. (2020), ‘Social diversity and social interaction: community integration and disintegration in inner-city districts of Tallinn and Warsaw’, Mitteilungen der Österreichischen geographischen Gesellschaft, 161, 91-115. Google Scholar

KORNAI, J. (1992), The Socialist System: The Political Economy of Communism, Oxford, Oxford University Press. Google Scholar

KOVÁCS, Z. and HERFERT, G. (2012), ‘Development pathways of large housing estates in post-socialist cities: an international comparison’, Housing Studies, 27, 324-42. Google Scholar

KRISJANE, Z. and BERZINS, M. (2012), ‘Post-socialist urban trends: new patterns and motivations for migration in the suburban areas of Rīga, Latvia’, Urban Studies, 49, 289-306. Google Scholar

KRYSAN, M. and CROWDER, K. (2017), Cycle of Segregation: Social Processes and Residential Stratification, New York, Russell Sage Foundation. Google Scholar

KUBEŠ, J. and KOVÁCS, Z. (2020), ‘The kaleidoscope of gentrification in post-socialist cities’, Urban Studies, 57, 2591-611. Google Scholar

KUUSK, K. and KURNITSKI, J. (2019), ‘State-subsidised refurbishment of socialist apartment buildings in Estonia’, in Hess and Tammaru (eds), 339-55. Google Scholar

LAN, T., KANDT, J. and LONGLEY, P. (2021), ‘Measuring the changing pattern of ethnic segregation in England and Wales with consumer registers’, Environment and Planning B: Urban Analytics and City Science, 48, 1591-608. Google Scholar

LEES, L., SHIN, H. B. and LÓPEZ-MORALES, E. (2016), Planetary Gentrification, Bristol, Policy Press. Google Scholar

LEETMAA, K. (2017), ‘Place of residence as a measure of integration: changes in ethno-linguistic residential segregation’ (Human development report 2016/2017: Estonia at the Age of Migration), Estonia, Eesti Koostöö Kogu, https://inimareng.ee/en/immigration-andintegration/place-of-residence-as-a-measure-of-integration/ (accessed 11 December 2017). Google Scholar

LEETMAA, K. and HESS, D. B. (2019), ‘Incomplete service networks in enduring socialist housing estates: retrospective evidence from local centres in Estonia’, in Hess and Tammaru (eds), 273-99. Google Scholar

LEETMAA, K., HOLVANDUS, J., MÄGI, K. and KÄHRIK, A. (2018), ‘Population shifts and urban policies in housing Estates of Tallinn, Estonia’, in Hess et al. (eds), 389-412. Google Scholar

LEETMAA, K., TAMMARU, T. and HESS, D. B. (2015), ‘Preferences toward neighbor ethnicity and affluence: evidence from an inherited dual ethnic context in post-Soviet Tartu, Estonia’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 105, 162-82. Google Scholar

LELÉVRIER, C. and MELIC, T. (2018), ‘Impoverishment and social fragmentation in housing estates of the Paris region, France’, in Hess et al. (eds), 313-38. Google Scholar

LIEPA-ZEMEŠA, M. and HESS, D. B. (2016), ‘Effects of public perception on urban planning: evolution of an inclusive planning system during crises in Latvia’, Town Planning Review, 87, 71-92. Google Scholar

LIHTMAA, L., HESS, D. B. and LEETMAA, K. (2018), ‘Intersection of the global climate agenda with regional development: unequal distribution of energy efficiency-based renovation subsidies for apartment buildings’, Energy Policy, 119, 327-38. Google Scholar

LOWE, S. (2003), ‘Introduction. Housing in post-communist Europe: issues and agendas’, in S. Lowe and S. Tsenkova (eds), Housing Change in East and Central Europe: Integration or Fragmentation?, London, Routledge, xiii-xix. Google Scholar

MCPHERSON, M., SMITH-LOVIN, L. and COOK, J. M. (2001), ‘Birds of a feather: homophily in social networks’, Annual Review of Sociology, 27, 415-44. Google Scholar

MADORÉ, F. (2004), Ségrégation sociale et habitat, Rennes, Presses universitaires de Rennes. Google Scholar

MALOUTAS, T. (2012), ‘Residential segregation in context’, in K. Fujita and T. Maloutas, Residential Segregation in Comparative Perspective: Making Sense of Contextual Diversity, Farnham, Ashgate, 1-36. Google Scholar

MALOUTAS, T. and FUJITA, K. (2012), Residential Segregation around the World: Why Context Matters, Farnham, Ashgate. Google Scholar

MANLEY, D., JOHNSTON, R. J., JONES, K. and OWEN, D. (2016), ‘Occupational segregation in London: a new framework for meddling segregation’, in Tammaru et al. (eds), 30-56. Google Scholar

MARCIŃCZAK, S., GENTILE, M. and STĘPNIAK, M. (2013), ‘Paradoxes of (post) socialist segregation: metropolitan sociospatial divisions under socialism and after in Poland’, Urban Geography, 34, 327-52. Google Scholar

MARCIŃCZAK, S. and HESS, D. B. (2020), ‘Vertical segregation of apartment building dwellers during late state socialism in Bucharest, Romania’, Urban Geography, 41, 823-48. Google Scholar

MARCIŃCZAK, S., TAMMARU, T., NOVÁK, J., GENTILE, M., KOVÁCS, Z., TEMELOVÁ, J., VALATKA, V., KÄHRIK, A. and SZABÓ, B. (2015), ‘Patterns of socioeconomic segregation in the capital cities of fast-track reforming postsocialist countries’, Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 105, 183−202. Google Scholar

MASSEY, D. S. and DENTON, N. (1993), American Apartheid: Segregation and the Making of the Underclass, Cambridge, MA, Harvard University Press. Google Scholar

MASSEY, D. S. (1985), ‘Ethnic residential segregation: a theoretical synthesis and empirical review’, Sociology and Social Research, 69, 315-50. Google Scholar

METSPALU, P. and HESS, D. B. (2018), ‘Revisiting the role of architects in planning large-scale housing in the USSR: the birth of socialist residential districts in Tallinn, Estonia, 1957-1979’, Planning Perspectives, 33, 335-61. Google Scholar

MEZENTSEV, K., GENTILE, M., MEZENTSEVA, N. and STEBLETSKA, I. (2019), ‘An island of civilization in a sea of delay? Indifference and fragmentation along the rugged shorelines of Kiev’s newbuild archipelago’, Journal of Urban Affairs, 41, 654-78. Google Scholar

MONKKONEN, P. and ZHANG, X. (2011), ‘Creating mixed-income neighborhoods unintentionally: public housing residualization and socioeconomic segregation in Hong Kong’, SSRN Electronic Journal, 2021662, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/256015335_Creating_Mixed-Income_Neighborhoods_Unintentionally_Public_Housing_Residualization_and_Socioeconomic_Segregation_in_Hong_Kong (accessed 1 December 2021). Google Scholar

MORGAN, B. (1975), ‘The segregation of socio-economic groups in urban areas: a comparative analysis’, Urban Studies, 12, 47-60. Google Scholar

MORGAN, B. (1980), ‘Occupational segregation in metropolitan areas in the United States, 1970’, Urban Studies, 17, 63-69. Google Scholar

MUSTERD, S., ANDERSSON, R., GALSTER, G. and KAUPPINEN, T. M. (2008), ‘Are immigrants’ earnings influenced by the characteristics of their neighbours?’, Environment and Planning A, 40, 785-805. Google Scholar

MUSTERD, S., MARCIŃCZAK, S., VAN HAM M. and TAMMARU, T. (2017), ‘Socio-economic segregation in European capital cities: increasing separation between poor and rich’, Urban Geography, 38, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/02723638.2016.1228371 (accessed 30 November 2021). Google Scholar

MUSTERD, S., PRIEMUS, H. and VAN KEMPEN, R. (1999), ‘Towards undivided cities: the potential of economic revitalisation and housing redifferentiation’, Housing Studies, 14, 573-84. Google Scholar

MUSTERD S., VAN GENT, W. P. C., DAS, M. and LATTEN, J. J. (2016), Adaptive behaviour in urban space: residential mobility in response to social distance’, Urban Studies, 53, 227-46. Google Scholar

NIEUWENHUIS, J. and XU, J. (2021), ‘Residential segregation and unequal access to schools’, Social Inclusion, Advance online publication, https://www.cogitatiopress.com/socialinclusion/article/view/3606 (accessed 1 December 2021). Google Scholar

NORRIS, M. and SHIELS, P. (2007), ‘Housing inequalities in an enlarged European Union: patterns, drivers, implications’, Journal of European Social Policy, 17, 65-76. Google Scholar

OGRODOWCZYK, A. and MARCIŃCZAK, S. (2021), ‘Market-based housing reforms and the residualization of public housing: the experience of Lodz, Poland’, Social Inclusion, 9, 91-103. Google Scholar

PARK, R. (1998; first published 1928), ‘Foreword’, in L. Wirth, The Ghetto, Chicago, The University of Chicago Press, lxv-lxvii. Google Scholar

PETERSDORFF, C., BOERMANS, T. and HARNISCH, J. (2006), ‘Mitigation of CO2 emissions from the EU-15 building stock: beyond the EU directive on the energy performance of buildings’, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 13, 350-58. Google Scholar

RONALD, R. and DEWILDE, C.(eds) (2017), Housing Wealth and Welfare, Northampton, MA, Edward Elgar Publishing. Google Scholar

ROSSI, P. H. (1955), Why Families Move: A Study in the Social Psychology of Urban Residential Mobility, Glencoe, The Free Press. Google Scholar

RUOPPILA, S. and KÃHRIK, A. (2003), ‘Socio-economic residential differentation in post-socialist Tallinn’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 18, 49-73. Google Scholar

SAAR, E. and HELEMÄE, J. (2017), ‘Rahvuslik segregatsioon Eesti tööturul’ in T. Tammaru, K. Kallas and R. Eamets (eds), Eesti inimarengu aruanne 2016/2017, Tallinn, Eesti Koostöö Kogu, 149-56. Google Scholar

SCANLON, K., FERNÁNDEZ ARRIGOITIA, M. and WHITEHEAD, C. M. E. (2015), ‘Social housing in Europe’, European Policy Analysis, 17, 1-12. Google Scholar

SCHELLING, T. C. (1971), ‘Dynamic models of segregation’, Journal of Mathematical Sociology, 1, 143-86. Google Scholar

ŠPAČKOVÁ, P. and OUŘEDNÍČEK, M. (2012), ‘Spinning the web: new social contacts of Prague’s suburbanites’, Cities, 29, 341-49. Google Scholar

STATISTICS ESTONIA (2017), Statistics Estonia online database, http://pub.stat.ee (accessed 29 August 2017). Google Scholar

SYKORA, L. and BOUZAROVSKI, S. (2012), ‘Multiple transformations: conceptualising the post-communist urban transition’, Urban Studies, 49, 43-60. Google Scholar

SZABÓ, B. and BURNEIKA, D. (2020), ‘The impact of social structure and physical characteristics on housing estate renovation in postsocialist cities: cases of Vilnius and Budapest’, Geographia Polonica, 93, 229-44. Google Scholar

TAMMARU, T., KÄHRIK, A., MÄGI, K., NOVÁK, J. and LEETMAA, K. (2016), ‘The “market experiment”: increasing socio-economic segregation in the inherited bi-ethnic context of Tallinn’, in Tammaru et al. (eds), 333-57. Google Scholar

TAMMARU, T., KNAPP, D., SILM, S., VAN HAM, M. and WITLOX, F. (2021), ‘Spatial underpinnings of social inequalities: a vicious circles of segregation approach’, Social Inclusion, 9, 65-76. Google Scholar

TAMMARU, T. and KULU, H. (2003), ‘The ethnic minorities of Estonia: changing size, location, and composition’, Eurasian Geography and Economics, 44, 105-20. Google Scholar

TAMMARU, T., MUSTERD, S., VAN HAM, M. and MARCIŃCZAK, S. (2016), ‘A multi-factor approach to understanding socio-economic segregation in European capital cities’, in Tammaru et al. (eds), 1-29. Google Scholar

TEMELOVÁ, J., NOVÁK, J., OUREDNIČEK, M. and PULDOVÁ, P. (2011), ‘Housing estates in the Czech Republic after socialism: various trajectories and inner differentiation’, Urban Studies, 48, 1811-34. Google Scholar

TORJUS, U. (2016), interview with Uku Torjus, head of the Health and Social Board of Tallinn, 3 November 2016. Google Scholar

TORPAN, K., SINITSYNA, A. KÄHRIK, A., KAUPPINEN, T. and TAMMARU, T. (2020), ‘Overlap of migrants’ housing and neighborhood mobility’, Housing Studies, published online, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/02673037.2020.1849574 (accessed 30 November 2021). Google Scholar

UBALDE, J. and ALARCÓN, A. (2020), ‘Immigrant disadvantage in the labour market: the role of attitudinal context’, European Societies, 22, 636-58. Google Scholar

VAATTOVAARA, M., JOUTSINIEMI, A., KORTTEINEN, M., STJERNBERG, M. and KEMPPAINEN, T. (2018), ‘Experience of a preventive experiment: spatial social mixing in post-World War II housing estates in Helsinki, Finland’, in Hess et al. (eds), 215-40. Google Scholar

VAN ASSCHE, K. and SALUKVADZE, J. (2012), ‘Tbilisi reinvented: planning, development and the unfinished project of democracy in Georgia’, Planning Perspectives, 27, 1-24. Google Scholar

VAN HAM, M., TAMMARU, T., UBAREVIČIENĖ, R. and JANSSEN, H. (2021), Urban Socio-economic Segregation and Income Inequality: A Global Perspective, Springer Online. Google Scholar

VAN KEMPEN, R., TURKINGTON, R. and WASSENBERG, M. (2004), High-Rise Housing in Europe: Current Trends and Future Prospects, Delft, Delft University Press. Google Scholar

VASILEVSKA, L., ZIVKOVIC, J. VASILEVSKA, M. and LALOVIC, K. (2020), ‘Revealing the relationship between city size and spatial transformation of large housing estates in post-socialist Serbia’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 35, 1099-121. Google Scholar

WASSENBERG, F. (2004), ‘Large social housing estates: from stigma to demolition?’, Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 19, 223-32. Google Scholar

WASSENBERG, F. (2013), Large Housing Estates: Ideas, Rise, Fall and Recovery. The Bijlmermeer and Beyond, Delft, Delft University Press. Google Scholar

WATT, P. (2021), Estate Regeneration and Its Discontents: Public Housing, Place and Inequality in London, Bristol, Policy Press. Google Scholar

WESSEL, T. (2016), ‘Economic segregation in Oslo: polarisation as a contingent outcome’, in Tammaru et al. (eds), 132-55. Google Scholar

WESSEL, T. and LUNKE, E. B. (2019), ‘Raising children in the inner city: still a mismatch between housing and households?’, Housing Studies, 36, 131-51. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Hess, Daniel Baldwin

Väiko, Annika

Tammaru, Tiit