Hunter Gatherer Research

The freedom to stop being free

Rethinking school education and personal autonomy among Nayaka children in South India

Hunter Gatherer Research (2019), 5, (1-2), 39–66.

Abstract

This paper examines education programmes for South Indian Nayaka, traditionally classified as hunter-gatherers and officially recognised as one of India’s poorest populations. With persistently high school dropout rates among their children, Nayaka parents find themselves today at the focus of formal education initiatives, constructed both as a central obstacle for children’s success in school and as responsible to facilitate it. The paper focuses on Nayaka’s sense of autonomy as a core social notion which is mainly practiced by avoidance from directing other’s actions and decisions, including children. The notion of autonomy plays a central role in constructing adult- child relations. I demonstrate how parents negotiate between conflicting senses of parenthood expected from them by development workers and educators on one hand and their families on the other. I argue that what is described by teachers as parental carelessness and lack of responsibility is in fact a deliberate and thoughtful avoidance from ordering others, which in turn encourages the development of children’s autonomy. I then show how the experience of school alters children’s sense of their own autonomy and as a result, their sense of their selves. Last, I explore the paradoxical role of the notion of autonomy in the unexpected trajectories of social change, when local attempts to maintain autonomy in contemporary circumstances in fact allow this value to diminish and thus invite significant social change. Overall, this paper demonstrates the importance of paying attention to local ideas for understanding the experience of development programmes and illuminate the pitfalls of education programmes.

Access Token
£25.00
READ THIS ARTICLE
If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

References

Anderson-Levitt, K 2003. A world culture of schooling. In Anderson-Levitt, K (ed) Local meanings, global schooling: anthropology and world culture theory. New York: Palgrave Macmillan:1-26. Google Scholar

Aries, P 1973. Centuries of childhood: a social history of family life. London: Penguin. Google Scholar

Balagopalan, S & Subrahmanian, R 2003. Dalit and Adivasi children in schools: some preliminary research themes and findings. IDS Bulletin 34:43-54. Google Scholar

Bird-David, N 1990. The giving environment: another perspective on the economic system of gatherer-hunters. Current Anthropology 31:189-196. Google Scholar

Bird-David, N 2008. Feeding Nayaka children and English readers: a bifocal ethnography of parental feeding in ‘the giving environment’. Anthropological Quarterly 81:523-550. Google Scholar

Bird-David, N 2017. Us, relatives: scaling and plural life in a forager world. Berkeley: University of California Press. Google Scholar

Boehm, C 1999. Hierarchy in the forest: the evolution of egalitarian behavior. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Google Scholar

Boyette, AH 2016. Children’s play and culture learning in an egalitarian foraging society. Child Development 87:759-769. Google Scholar

Boyette, AH & Hewlett BS 2017. Autonomy, equality, and teaching among Aka foragers and Ngandu farmers of the Congo Basin. Human Nature 31:1-34. Google Scholar

Christian, J & Gardner, P 1977. The individual in Northern Dene thought and communication: a study in sharing and diversity. Ottawa: National Museums of Canada. Google Scholar

Draper, P 1976. Social and economic constraints on child life among the !Kung. In Lee, RB & and DeVore, I (eds) Kalahari hunter-gatherers: studies of the !Kung San and their neighbours. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press:199-217. Google Scholar

Draper, P & Cashdan, E 1988. Technological change and child behavior among the !Kung. Ethnology 27:339-365. Google Scholar

Endicott, KL 1999. Gender relations in hunter-gatherer societies. In Lee, RB & Daly, R (eds) The Cambridge encyclopaedia of hunters and gatherers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:411-418. Google Scholar

Endicott, KL & Endicott, KM 2014. Batek childrearing and morality. In Narvaez, D, Valentino, K, Fuentes, A, McKenna, JJ & Gray, P (eds) Ancestral landscapes in human evolution. Oxford: Oxford University Press:108-125. Google Scholar

Endicott, KM & Endicott, KL 2008. The headman was a woman. Long Grove: Wavekand. Google Scholar

Fortier, J 2009. The ethnography of South Asian foragers. Annual Review of Anthropology 38:99-114. Google Scholar

Gallois, S, Duda, R, Hewlett, BS & Reyes-García, V 2015. Children’s daily activities and knowledge acquisition: a case study among the Baka from southeastern Cameroon. Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicine 11:86-99. Google Scholar

Gardner, PM 1966. Symmetric respect and memorate knowledge: the structure and ecology of individualistic culture. Southwestern Journal of Anthropology 22:389-415. Google Scholar

Gardner, PM 1991. Foragers’ pursuit of individual autonomy. Current Anthropology 31:543-572. Google Scholar

Gardner, PM 2000. Bicultural versatility as a frontier adaptation among Paliyan foragers of South India. Lewiston: Edwin Mellen Press. Google Scholar

Gibson, T & Sillander, K 2011. Anarchic solidarity: autonomy, equality, and fellowship in Southeast Asia. New Haven, CT: Yale University Southeast Asia Studies Monographs. Google Scholar

Hays, J 2016a. Owners of learning: the Nyae Nyae village schools over twenty-five years. Basel: Basler Afrika Bibliografien. Google Scholar

Hays, J 2016b. Who owns education? Schooling, learning and livelihood for the Nyae Nyae Ju|’hoansi. Journal of Namibian Studies 20:37-61. Google Scholar

Hewlett, BL 2012. Listen, here’s a story: ethnographic life narratives from Aka and Ngandu women of the Congo Basin. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Google Scholar

Hewlett, BS 1992. The parent-child relationship and social emotional development among Aka pygmies. In Roopnarine, JL & Carter, DB (eds) Parent-child relations in diverse cultures. Norwood: Ablex Publishing:223-243. Google Scholar

Hewlett, BS, Fouts, HN, Boyette, AH & Hewlett, BL 2011. Social learning among Congo Basin hunter-gatherers. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 366:1168-1178. Google Scholar

Hewlett, BS, Lamb, ME, Leyendecker, B & Scholmerich, A 2000. Internal working models, trust, and sharing among foragers. Current Anthropology 41:287-297. Google Scholar

Hunt, F 2008. Dropping out of school: a cross country review of literature. Brighton: University of Sussex. Google Scholar

Ingold, T 2000. The perception of the environment: essays in livelihood, dwelling and skill. London: Routledge. Google Scholar

James, A & Prout, A 2015. Constructing and reconstructing childhood: contemporary issues in the sociological study of childhood. London: Routledge. Google Scholar

Jayaswal, M, Sinha, SK, Kumari, K & Arora, A 2003. Parental support and academic achievement in tribal school students of Jharkhand. Journal of All India Association for Educational Research 15:9-16. Google Scholar

Jejeebhoy, SJ 2002. Convergence and divergence in spouses: perspectives on women’s autonomy in rural India. Studies in Family Planning 33:299-308. Google Scholar

Jenks, C 2005. Childhood: critical concepts in sociology. London: Routledge. Google Scholar

Jensen, T 2010. Warmth and wealth: re-imagining social class in taxonomies of good parenting. Studies in the Maternal 2:1-13. Google Scholar

Kakkoth, S 2014. Square pegs in round holes: perceptions of hunter-gatherer school dropouts of Kerala, South India. Eastern Anthropologist 67:433-450. Google Scholar

Kamei, N 2005. Play among Baka children in Cameroon. In Hewlett, BS & Lamb, ME (eds) Hunter-gatherer childhoods: evolutionary, developmental and cultural perspectives. New Brunswick: Transaction:343-362. Google Scholar

Kapadia, K 1995. Siva and her sisters: gender, caste, and class in rural South India. Boulder, CO: Westview. Google Scholar

Kelly RL 1995. The foraging spectrum. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press. Google Scholar

Lavi, N 2018. ‘Developing relations’: rethinking the experience of aid and development interventions, a case study from the Nayaka of South India. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Haifa. Google Scholar

Lavi, N 2021. "We only teach them how to be together": parenting, child development, and engagement with formal education among the Nayaka in south India. Anthropology & Education Quarterly 53(1):84-102. Google Scholar

Lavi, N & Bird-David, N 2014. At home under development: a housing project for the hunter-gatherers Nayaka of the Nilgiris. Eastern Anthropologist 67:407-432. Google Scholar

Leacock, E & Lee, RB 1982. Introduction. In Leacock, E & Lee, RB (eds) Politics and history in band societies. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press:1-20. Google Scholar

Lew-Levy, S, Lavi, N, Reckin, R, Cristobal-Azkarate, J & Ellis-Davies, K 2018. How do hunter-gatherer children learn social and gender norms? A meta-ethnographic review. Cross-Cultural Research 52:213-255. Google Scholar

Lew-Levy, S, Reckin, R, Lavi, N, Cristobal-Azkarate, J & Ellis-Davies, K 2017. How do hunter-gatherer children learn subsistence skills? A meta-ethnographic review. Human Nature 28:367-394. Google Scholar

Maithreyi, R & Sriprakash, A 2018 The governance of families in India: education, rights and responsibility. Comparative Education 54:352-369. Google Scholar

Martin, DF 1993. Autonomy and relatedness: an ethnography of Wik people of Aurukun, Western Cape York Peninsula. Unpublished PhD thesis, Australian National University. Google Scholar

Mary, MJ 2013. Effect of household community and school factors on access, enrolment, retention and achievement of Scheduled Tribe girls at primary level. Kottayam: DC Books. Google Scholar

Morelli, G, Rogoff, B & Angelillo, C 2003. Cultural variation in young children’s access to work or involvement in specialized child-focused activities. International Journal of Behavioural Development 27:264-274. Google Scholar

Morris, B 1982. Forest traders: a socio-economic study of the Hill Pandaram. London: Athlone Press. Google Scholar

Myers, F 1986. Pintupi country, Pintupi self: sentiment, place and politics among Western Desert aborigine. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Institution Press and Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies. Google Scholar

Naveh, D 2014. Knowing and learning among Nayaka hunter-gatherers. Eastern Anthropologist 67:345-362. Google Scholar

Naveh, D 2016. Social and epistemological dimensions of learning among Nayaka hunter-gatherers. In Terashima, H & Hewlett, BS (eds) Social learning and innovation in contemporary hunter-gatherers. Tokyo: Springer Japan:125-133. Google Scholar

Neuwelt-Truntzer, S 1981. Ecological influences on the physical, behavioral, and cognitive development of pygmy children. Unpublished PhD thesis, University of Chicago. Google Scholar

Nieuwenhuys, O 2010. Keep asking: Why childhood? Why children? Why global? Childhood 17:291-296. Google Scholar

Pandita, R 2015. Dropout percentage of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe children in India: a decadal analysis up to secondary level. Journal of Indian Education XXXXI:97-117. Google Scholar

Pridmore, P 2007. The impact of health on education access and attainment: a cross-national review of the research evidence. London: CREATE and Institute of Education, University of London. Google Scholar

Rajam, V & Malarvizhi, V 2011. A study on educational status of tribal children in the Nilgiri district. ZENITH International Journal of Business Economics & Management Research 1:197-210. Google Scholar

Raman, V 2000. Politics of childhood: perspectives from the South. Economic and Political Weekly 35:4055-4064. Google Scholar

Sahu, KK 2014. Challenging issues of tribal education in India. IOSR-Journal of Economics and Finance 3:48-52. Google Scholar

Secada, WG 1989. Educational equity versus equality of education: an alternative conception. In Secada, WG (ed) Equity in education. New York: Falmer Press:68-88. Google Scholar

Sedwal, M & Kamat, S 2008. Education and social equity with a special focus on scheduled castes and Scheduled Tribes in elementary education. Brighton: Consortium for Research on Educational Access, Transitions and Equity (CREATE). Google Scholar

Serpell, R 1994. The cultural construction of intelligence. In Lonner, WL & Malpass, RS (eds) Psychology and culture. Boston: Allyn Bacon:157-163. Google Scholar

Singh, P 1989. Problem of education among scheduled castes: a comparative study of achievement, adjustment, attitudes, and problems of first and subsequent generation learners belonging to scheduled castes at higher secondary level. Bew Delhi: Mittal. Google Scholar

Sujatha, K 2002. Education among Scheduled Tribes. In Govinda, R (ed) India education report: a profile of basic education. New Delhi: Oxford University Press:87-94. Google Scholar

Thane, P 1981. Childhood in history. In King, M (ed) Childhood, welfare and justice. London: Batsford:6-25. Google Scholar

Willerslev, R 2007. Soul hunters: hunting, animism, and personhood among the Siberian Yukaghirs. Berkeley: University of California Press. Google Scholar

Woodburn, J 1982. Egalitarian societies. Man 17:431-451. Google Scholar

If you have private access to this content, please log in with your username and password here

Details

Author details

Lavi, Noa