The turbulent reign of Stephen, King of England (1135–54), has been styled since the late 19th century as 'the Anarchy’, although the extent of political breakdown during the period has since been vigorously debated. Rebellion and bitter civil war characterised Stephen’s protracted struggle with rival claimant Empress Matilda and her Angevin supporters over ‘nineteen long winters’ when, according to the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, ‘Christ and his Saints slept’. Drawing on new research and fieldwork, this innovative volume offers the first ever overview and synthesis of the archaeological and material record for this controversial period. It presents and interrogates many different types of evidence at a variety of scales, ranging from nationwide mapping of historical events through to conflict landscapes of battlefields and sieges. The volume considers archaeological sites such as castles and other fortifications, churches, monasteries, bishops’ palaces and urban and rural settlements, alongside material culture including coins, pottery, seals and arms and armour. This approach not only augments but also challenges historical narratives, questioning the ‘real’ impact of Stephen’s troubled reign on society, settlement, church and the landscape, and opens up new perspectives on the conduct of Anglo-Norman warfare
Duncan W. Wright is Senior Lecturer in Archaeology and Heritage at Bishop Grosseteste University.
Oliver H. Creighton is Professor of Archaeology at the University of Exeter.
List of Figures
Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 2: Historical Outline and the Geography of Anarchy
Chapter 3: Waging War: Fields of Conflict and Siege Warfare
Chapter 4: Architecture and Authority: Castles
Chapter 5: Artefacts and the Arts: Twelfth-Century Material Culture
Chapter 6: Performing Violence: Arms, Armour and Military Apparel
Chapter 7: Faith and Fortification: The Church
Chapter 8: Village, Town and Country
Chapter 9: Anarchy on the Fen Edge: Case Study of the Isle of Ely
Chapter 9: The Twelfth-Century Civil War in Context: An Assessment
Appendix: Sites to visit
This excellent book reexamines “the Anarchy,” or the period of civil war between King Stephen and his cousin Mathilda (1135–54), integrating into the substantial historiography of the period a growing data set of archaeological findings and the insights of landscape studies to better illuminate the problems of the period. Although the book necessarily constitutes a sort of interim report, given the ongoing accumulation of material culture finds and excavations, it is a completely successful one that both synthesizes extant knowledge and points to potentially fruitful paths for further field research. British archaeologists Creighton (Univ. of Exeter) and Wright (Bishop Grosseteste Univ., Lincoln) examine castles and siege works, military equipment, churches and towns, and daily objects, including coinage. Their conclusions point in seemingly contradictory but, in fact, comprehensible directions. "The Anarchy” was not terribly anarchic in most places, and the period left no archaeological “event horizon” in most ways, save perhaps for an increase in monastic foundations. But it has left evidence of changes in the physical display of lordship, and the war likely accelerated 12th-century trends that transformed the English landscape far more than the 1066 conquest did. Illustrated with many excellent maps, drawings, and photographs. For archaeologists and social, cultural, and military historians.
S. Morillo, Wabash College
It successfully combines detailed archaeological considerations with careful historical assessment and thereby offers an important source for a range of scholars of military history, landscape studies and medieval archaeology... Certainly we learn a lot more about the ‘Anarchy’ and its various impacts and manifestations, and the ongoing problems with finding and reading the archaeology of the period. Dr Neil Christie, University of Leicester
January 5, 2017
Exeter Studies in Medieval Europe